caribbean vs carnival cruise

• Port Overview
• Transportation to the Port
• Uber & Lyft to the Port
• Dropping Off at the Port
• Cruise Parking
• Cruise Hotels
• Hotels with Parking Deals
• Uber & Lyft to the Ports
• Things to Do
• Cozumel Taxi Rates
• Free Things to Do
• Restaurants Near the Cruise Port
• Hotels & Resorts With Day Passes
• Closest Beaches to the Cruise Port
• Tips For Visiting
• Shore Excursions
• Cruise Parking Discounts
• Hotels with Shuttles
• Which Airport Should I Use?
• Transportation to the Ports
• Dropping Off at the Ports
• Fort Lauderdale Airport to Miami
• Inexpensive Hotels
• Hotels near the Port
• Hotels With Shuttles
• Budget Hotels
• Carnival Tips
• Drink Packages
• Specialty Restaurants
• Faster to the Fun
• More Articles
• CocoCay Tips
• Norwegian Tips
• Great Stirrup Cay
• Harvest Caye
• How to Get the Best Cruise Deal
• Best Time to Book a Cruise
• Best Websites to Book a Cruise
• Cruises Under $300
• Cruises Under $500
• Spring Break Cruise Deals
• Summer Cruise Deals
• Alaskan Cruise Deals
• 107 Cruise Secrets & Tips
• Tips for First-Time Cruisers
• What to Pack for a Cruise
• What to Pack (Alaska)
• Packing Checklist
• Cruising with Kids
• Passports & Birth Certificates
• Bringing Alcohol
• Cruising with a Disability
• Duty-Free Shopping
• Cruise Travel Insurance
• Things to Do on a Cruise Ship
• What Not to Do on a Ship
• News & Articles

12 Major Differences Between Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line

While there are a lot of cruise lines out there, when it comes to the United States, two main players come to mind: Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean.

That’s for good reason. The two cruise lines are by far the most popular in the country, with millions of cruise passengers sailing on their ships each year. In fact, they are the two lines that we’ve personally sailed the most, so we have a lot of direct experience in how they compare.

If you’ve never taken a cruise… or you’ve only sailed with one cruise line or the other… then you’d be forgiven for thinking that both Carnival and Royal Caribbean are exactly the same.

While both lines do have a lot of similarities, there are also some major differences.

Anyone that is loyal to either Carnival or Royal Caribbean would tell you as much. To be sure, you’re bound to have fun on either company’s ships, however, if you want the real scoop on how they differ, we’ve laid out some of the major differences below.

Cost of Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival

Want to sail affordably? Both Royal Caribbean and Carnival offer affordable vacations. If you want to sail the more inexpensive cruise line, however, then you’re better off with Carnival according to our analysis.

About a year ago, we analyzed dozens of cruises from both cruise lines departing from three of their most popular ports. Carnival and Royal Caribbean both sail from Miami, Port Canaveral, and Galveston, which gives an ability to compare prices across the lines with similar trips.

When looking at the fares for each sailing in July (the peak of the cruise season in North America), we found that Carnival’s fares are less expensive on average.

According to our analysis, cruise fare for a 5-night trip aboard Carnival was about $50 cheaper per person during our search than what was seen on Royal Caribbean. That lower average pricing also held no matter the cruise length.

(Note: Royal Caribbean’s 7-night average in our analysis includes trips aboard Icon of the Seas. This ship features prices considerably higher than other ships.)

Now keep in mind that this doesn’t mean your cruise will automatically be less expensive on Carnival or more expensive on Royal Caribbean.  What you pay for a cruise depends on a lot of factors, including when you sail, the specific ship you choose, and the route you take. But in general, you can figure that a Carnival cruise will run less than a similar one on Royal Caribbean.

Bottom line: When it comes to cost, Carnival is usually cheaper to sail than a similar trip on Royal Caribbean, but prices for specific trips will vary.

Size of Ships

While both cruise lines have ships ranging from older, smaller vessels to brand new mega-ships, Royal Caribbean and Carnival’s vessels definitely differ. Royal Caribbean is well known for having the largest cruise ships in the world. And while Carnival’s ships can be of comparable length, the overall size of Royal Caribbean’s biggest ships is noticeable.

Consider that Royal Caribbean’s Wonder of the Seas is nearly 1,200 feet and carries more than 5,700 guests at double occupancy. And that’s just one of several in it Oasis-class fleet. Overall, it has a gross tonnage of 237,000 tons. 

Today, Icon of the Seas takes over as the largest cruise ship in the world and comes in at more than 250,000 gross tons. All told, the top six largest cruise ships on the planet belong to Royal Caribbean .

Carnival Celebration, Jubilee, and Mardi Gras, Carnival’s largest ships, have a gross tonnage of 183,000, or about 75% of the size of Royal’s largest ship. And this is just one example. When it comes to size, Royal Caribbean ships definitely have an edge.

Of course, with larger ships you can pack a lot more onto the vessel. While both cruise lines take advantage of all the space on their ship, you’ll see below that there are major differences in activities and entertainment between the two cruise lines due partly to the ship size.

Bottom line: If you want to travel on the biggest cruise ships, then Royal Caribbean is the clear winner. It sails the largest ships in the world, and the fleet as a whole is on average larger.

Activities & Entertainment

You might not realize it, but the vast majority of your time on a cruise is actually spent on the ship. Even on days in port, the ship is normally docked for only about eight hours. That means the activities and entertainment on the ship are important to the fun you’ll have.

Good news — both cruise lines offer constant entertainment. In fact, we find that the entertainment like evening shows, comedians, onboard contests, evening game shows, casino gaming and more are very similar between the two lines. (Though we do have to acknowledge the Aqua Theater shows aboard Oasis and Icon-class ships as unique to Royal Caribbean.)

But when it comes to activities on board, we think Royal Caribbean and Carnival are very different.

Royal Caribbean definitely seems more innovative with the things to do on the ship. Newer ships include the world’s tallest slide at sea, bumper cars, ice skating, a surf simulator, escape rooms, and even an observation pod that can take you up and out over the water on some ships. Icon of the Seas debuts a full-fledged water park with six slides.

Carnival offers plenty of fun things to do as well, but it’s typically more of the classic things to do on a cruise ship, like mini-golf, movies, pools, and jogging tracks (which Royal Caribbean also has).

That said, Carnival is moving in the direction of Royal Caribbean. For instance, Mardi Gras and Carnival Celebration and Jubilee have the first-ever roller coaster at sea , and the cruise line is the only one to have an IMAX on some of its ships.

Bottom line: While the entertainment on board may be similar, the activities on Royal Caribbean are more innovative in our opinion. 

Ports of Departure

One of the biggest benefits to the growth of the cruise industry? As cruise lines grow their fleet, they are able to add more cruises — including from smaller ports.

Are you near a major cruise port like Miami or Galveston ? The good news is that you have your choice of either cruise line. You’ll find both lines in any port with heavy cruise traffic.

If you are close to a smaller cruise port like Mobile, Jacksonville, or Charleston, then you’ll be glad to know you still can sail aboard Carnival. Royal Caribbean is catching up in this regard, sailing from spots like Baltimore and New Orleans.

What’s so nice about sailing from smaller ports is that it means more people can cruise without the added expense of flying. The added cost of plane tickets on top of a cruise can be burdensome for some people who would otherwise set sail.

Bottom line: Carnival offers up trips from a number of smaller ports. Yes, trips from smaller ports are usually aboard smaller and older ships, but we think any cruise is better than no cruise.

Space Ratio

One complaint that many people have — especially with the size of modern ships — is that there are too many people. Well, that’s just become a fact of life on cruises, but where there is a difference between the two lines is how much space those people have on the ship.

There’s no perfect measure of this as ship design can have as much to do with the elbow room you feel than anything. But we like to use something called the space ratio . This is simply the gross tonnage of a ship divided by the occupancy at double occupancy. Essentially, this is how big a ship is per passenger.

In that regard, there’s a marked difference. Royal Caribbean ships consistently measure in the low 40s in this segment, no matter whether a ship is new or old. Carnival has a few that measure in the 40s, but most are around 34-37, meaning a significantly smaller size per passenger.

In other words, if you’ve felt that Carnival feels more cramped, it might not be your imagination.

Bottom line: If you want more elbow room, then Royal Caribbean generally offers more space than Carnival on their ships.

Drink Package Rules & Pricing

On a cruise, alcoholic drinks are a big business. It’s not unusual to pay $7-9 for a beer, or $11-14 for a cocktail. At those prices, the bar tab can add up quickly.

To help passengers budget, cruise lines have drink packages . The packages allow you to pay one set daily price and then you can get what you want, without worrying about the bill.

There are differences, however, between Carnival and Royal Caribbean when it comes to these packages. 

First, Carnival’s CHEERS! package is less expensive than what you’ll usually find on Royal Caribbean. Carnival charges around $60 per day (if bought ahead of the cruise), while Royal Caribbean uses dynamic pricing where the price depends on your specific cruise. However, in general you can expect it to be more than what Carnival charges.

As well, Carnival has a 15-drink limit over 24-hour period for alcoholic beverages (non-alcoholic drinks are unlimited), while Royal Caribbean makes no mention of a limit.

Bottom line: Both lines offer drink packages, but Carnival’s rates are normally lower than Royal Caribbean. As well, Carnival makes an explicit limit of 15 alcoholic drinks per 24-hour period.

Atmosphere on Board

While it’s hard to explain, Carnival and Royal Caribbean just have a different “feel” to most passengers. It’s purely anecdotal, but you’ll hear many say that Carnival has more of a laid-back party atmosphere.

Want to have a margarita and dance in conga line around the pool? Let’s just say, there’s good reason that Carnival is known as the “Fun Ships.” In our experience, folks on both cruise lines love to have a great time, but seem more outgoing on Carnival.

To us, Royal Caribbean has more of a luxury feel. That’s not to say it’s stuffy (far from it), however, it feels more subdued than Carnival. There are still plenty of chances to party, but we think there is simply a slightly different feel on Royal Caribbean.

Either way, you’ll have plenty of fun.

Bottom line: Both ships have a fun atmosphere and are similar, but the vibe on Carnival is a bit more “outgoing” than what we’ve found on Royal Caribbean.

Costs on Board

When you cruise, you should really think of having two different costs for the trip. There’s the cruise fare, which is by far the biggest bulk of what you’ll spend. But then there is also the spending you’ll do on the ship including things like drinks, wi-fi, excursions, specialty restaurants, and more. 

The good news is that this spending is optional. If you don’t want to spend anything on the ship, you don’t have to. But if you do spend, then you’ll likely find that Carnival is less expensive than Royal Caribbean. 

For instance, specialty cocktails on Royal Caribbean were recently seen at $14 per glass. On Carnival, they run more in the $10-12 range.  The same goes for the drink package, discussed above. It’s less expensive on Carnival.

We will say that since the pandemic and the rise in inflation Carnival’s prices seem to be creeping up to match Royal Caribbean. For instance, the highest-tier Internet on Carnival is now up to $25 per day if bought on the ship. Still, at this point we’d say that Carnival generally offers lower prices around the ship.

Bottom line: In general, the prices on Royal Caribbean seem higher than what you’ll spend on Carnival. 

Worldwide Sailings

Are you a Royal Caribbean fan, but also love to travel the world? In that case, you are in luck. The cruise line has trips sailing everywhere from the United States to Asia to Europe. While most trips are from the U.S., there are a number of other options if you are a fan of the cruise line but want to experience somewhere new.

In comparison, Carnival is more focused on the United States with their sailings. Outside of a handful of trips in Europe, there isn’t much available that isn’t based in the U.S. The one exception is Australia. Carnival does offer some trips from Brisbane and Sydney for Carnival fans in the southern hemisphere. 

Bottom line: Royal Caribbean offers more sailings from a variety of spots around the world. Carnival is mainly U.S.-focused, although Australia is well-represented in their sailings.

Private Destinations

For years cruise lines have had private islands. These islands had largely been the same, offering some restaurants and shops, but the big draw being white-sand beaches with beautiful water. These spots offer snorkeling, beach activities, kayaking, and other beach activities.

However, that’s changed with the recent renovation of CocoCay by Royal Caribbean. The cruise line spent $250 million to completely transform the place from a sleepy tropical island to a full-blown destination. Today CocoCay features a full waterpark with one of the tallest slides in the world, a massive freshwater pool, restaurants, and tons more. 

Carnival does have its own private destinations that are a lot of fun (Grand Turk, Amber Cove, among others), but they aren’t the same league as what CocoCay can offer as far as things to do. However, that will be changing. The cruise line has broken ground on Celebration Key, a new destination in The Bahamas , scheduled for 2025 that will be even larger than Royal Caribbean’s offering.

Bottom line: Royal Caribbean’s CocoCay gives it the lead in private islands and marks a big difference with Carnival. In the coming years, however, Carnival is set to debut a massive private destination of its own that should be on par.

Dynamic Pricing

If you are a budgeter, then one of the frustrating things you might encounter is dynamic pricing on Royal Caribbean. With this type of pricing, there isn’t a set cost for something like a specialty restaurant or drink package. Instead, the price will vary based on the specific cruise you take. So you could sail one cruise and see one price, but a completely different price the next time you sail.

Royal Caribbean has dynamic pricing on many things. For instance, the cruise line adjust prices on drink packages. And admission to Thrill Waterpark on CocoCay has also been higher or lower (including some prices of more than $150!) depending on the individual cruise.

Not having a set price can make it tougher to budget before you buy your cruise as you won’t know the price of some items on the ship until you are booked. 

Carnival, on the other hand, has more traditional pricing that doesn’t change from trip to trip (at least right now). So even if you haven’t booked, you’ll have a good idea of how much things will cost on the ship.

Bottom line: Royal Caribbean has prices that can vary from cruise to cruise while Carnival has more traditional pricing based on our experience.

Food Offerings

What’s a cruise without food? This is one area that the cruise lines differ a little bit. You won’t go hungry, and both offer tasty options. Where the difference lies is in your free versus paid choices.

In our opinion, Carnival has more and better “free” options. One of the most popular places on the ship is Guy’s Burger Joint — a tasty fresh-grilled burger with seasoned fries. If you want to eat there, it’s free. As well, there is also BlueIguana Cantina, Pizzeria del Capitano and a few other places where you can grab a bite (ChiBang!, Big Chicken, the deli) without any additional charge. And some spots that charge for dinner also have free lunch options.

Royal Caribbean definitely has free places to eat (larger ships tend to have more free options), but in our opinion the freebies outside of the buffet and dining room seem to be more snacks than meals. Meanwhile, the cruise line seems to focus more on specialty restaurants that charge extra. And those specialty restaurants tend to lean more toward fancier, high-end eats than Carnival.

Bottom line: While both lines won’t leave you hungry, in our opinion Carnival offers more tasty free options that are included in your fare.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Carnival better than Royal Caribbean or vice versa? Like most preferences, the decision of which cruise line is better is subjective. Many people are steadfast fans of one ship over another — and won’t hear anything otherwise. In our opinion, both offer an experience that’s about 80% the same. It’s that other 20% that may sway you one way or another. Like big ships with lots to do? Royal Caribbean may be for you. Like more free dining options and a fun atmosphere? You’ll enjoy Carnival.

I have the choice between a Royal Caribbean cruise and a Carnival cruise. Which should I pick? If you have two cruises — one from each cruise line — that you are choosing between, then it’s a good problem to have! To help you decide, we’d suggest taking into account a few items like the ship ( we think newer is better ), the cost, and the ports of call. The good news is that you’ll have fun on either line.

What about a different cruise line like Norwegian? You might realize that Carnival and Royal Caribbean are not your only choices. There are a number of cruise lines out there. In terms of larger lines, Norwegian is one of the other options for many passengers. If you want to know more about it, you can read the differences between Carnival and Norwegian or the differences between Royal Caribbean and Norwegian .

Have more questions about sailing Royal Caribbean or Carnival? Let us know in the comments below.

Popular: 39 Useful Things to Pack (17 You Wouldn't Think Of)

Read next: park & cruise hotels for every port in america, popular: 107 best cruise tips, secrets, tricks, and freebies.

RELATED ARTICLES MORE FROM AUTHOR

Carnival vifp club: how it works, benefits, and more, should you buy carnival’s ‘faster to the fun’ deal here’s when it’s worth it, worth it everything to know about hideaway beach on royal caribbean’s cococay, how to enjoy cococay… without spending a dime, six icon-class cruise ships royal caribbean signs agreement for that option, what to do on a cruise 70 fun things to do on the ship, 31 comments.

Thanks for this article! My family just went on our first cruise on Carnival and we loved it!! Our hearts were filled with so much joy. We can’t wait until our next cruise!

We’re gold members on Carnival. We’re accustomed to everything Carnival so we’re not usually surprised by little things around the ship… depending on ship size. On the Horizon, a dip in the pool is really nice and a lot of fun. On the Paradise, there isn’t 1 square inch available all day. People stay in the pool ordering drinks and beer from there… one good thing, there’s never a line to the bathroom!

One big difference between Royal Caribbean and Carnival is the rewards are much better for repeat cruisers on Royal Caribbean. I’m Platinum on Carnival and Diamond on RC (they also match on Celebrity to Elite status). Diamond Lounge or four free drinks any time of day at almost any bar, some free internet, free photo and a few other extras.

We leave Sat on RC! We usually do Carnival! So far I am not impressed one bit with RC! You have to make reservations for all shows and they are already booked out, before boarding! We were assigned to 2:00 pm boarding, so that means when we get onboard and are able to book the leftover show times won’t be much left! How disappointed that we paid for 2 rooms with 4 guests and this what you get! Even with the anytime dining the first time available for dinner was 8:45 pm! So we changed to early dining! It’s sad that you have to have everything planned out that far in advance the whole week to get a spot! With Carnival you just don’t have this!

I hear you. But with the shows, you can arrive early and without a reservation almost always still get in! Enjoy your cruise on Royal, we did!

how often does the entertainment change? like comedies? and other shows ? while i loved everything on royal caribbean if i went again in the next 6 months i would want to see something different.

We tend to try all kind of different cruise lines. But we end up cruising with Carnival more often (not something by choice, just because we live close to Long Beach port). Something significantly different in our experience with Carnival is their cruise directors. We always remembered the names of cruise directors on Carnival ships, they worked so hard to entertain and take care the guests. They were fun. On the contrary, we took multiple Royal, Celebrity, NCL cruises, we rarely saw the cruise directors, in many cases, we didn’t even know they had one on the cruise.

Carnival cruise line is all about taking your money, we recently took a cruise for 8 days and had 4 islands when booked but only stop at 1. They allowed us to board the cruise ship with staff having Covid19 and of course it spread to passengers, so for 6days we’re at sea giving a credit of $100 onboard credit per room. I have been trying to contact Company and no response as well as I filed a complaint with no response I’m a gold card traveler with Carnival and this was my final cruise with them.I learned something that cheaper is not always better. Royal Caribbean had a similar issue and they gave their Passengers 50 percent of their money back and 50 percent off their next Cruise. I want to feel like I’m appreciated too for being a loyal customer, so Royal Caribbean here my family come!!!

Thank you Tanner. This was a very informative article. I’ve been sailing on Carnival Cruise Lines for the past 15 years and this year my husband decided to change to Royal Caribbean just to get some variety. We will set sail in April and I’m looking forward to it. However, I did notice when booking the cruise how they try to encourage you to pre-purchase all the extras. So we opted to wait and see if the complimentary offerings are going to be enough. If not, we will know next time if it would be worth that extra money. Again, I do appreciate articles like this one that help consumers make good decisions about how to spend their time and money and get the most out of it. God Bless.

Glad you like it. If you have specific questions about what is included, let us know. In our opinion Carnival has more things included in your fare — most specifically we feel like there are more included food options.

Is there a drink package that can be purchased for alcoholic and non alcoholic drinks on RC

Absolutely. You can get a soda package or an alcoholic drink package.

Those replying about Royal Caribbean seem to have had very different then I have. I have been on almost 60 different cruise with Royal and all have been excellent. We have NEVER had an excursion leave late either so not sure what that one person was experiencing. The venues to eat on there larger ships are very impressive. On the Oasis class ships they have Central Park Cafe where you get to make your own salad or choose from hot sliced roast beef sandwiches and put au jus and horseradish if you want. For fun they have ice skating, 2 Flow riders for surfing, rock climbing, giant water slides. They have a water show where you sit and watch a complete water show with divers from 100 ft up doing various tricks. Their promenade deck is amazing, and they have a Central Park area with trees and all. From the promenade you can sit at the rising tide bar and literally go from deck 5 to deck 8 as your bar rises in the air. They have all the characters from Dreamworks for the younger sailors. The WIndjammers has plenty of various food to select from. The Solarium is for those who do not want children around them at the pool but these ships have many pools for all ages and desires. The kids pool has water cannons and other things for the kids to play with. Oh forgot it even has zip lining. I have been on so many ships with my kids and without, we have locked in on Royal due to the variety of things to do on board. Sometimes we do sail Celebrity which is also owned by Royal. Just my two cents. Enjoy, YOLO!!!

I loved Carnival , caring staff and nice food service. They even serve vegetarian meals.👍🏼

How much does it cost for children under 17 on each ship.

The age doesn’t make a difference in the price charged. However, if traveling as a third passenger in a cabin, there is a discounted rate.

The quality and variety of food on Royal Caribbean seems to depend on the size of the ship, sometimes. It is only as good as the chef’s they have and the space they have. That being said, we’ve been on a ship with approximately 1200 passengers and the food was wonderful. We were recently on a ship of approximately 3200 passengers and the food varied greatly between the buffet, the main restaurant and the specialty restaurants.

The layout of the ship was terrible and the buffet was very small for the number of passengers. The buffet variety tended towards junk food with very little healthy food and very little variety from day to day. The traditional dining menu did not seem typical of what we’ve had in the past. We have cruised since 2006, mainly on RCL, but have cruised on Holland America, Celebrity and Norwegian. We cruise at least once per year, but often twice per year. This year was extremely disappointing on a number of aspects.

This post would go too long if I posted what happened with everything so I will just touch on some of them; distance from ship to boat into Venice was further than told, much too far for older people to walk without having to get someone to get them a wheelchair; suddenly notified of a fee to take the boat back & forth to Venice at the last minute.(on top of the walk back to the ship), even if you have an excursion, told if you have an excursion to Venice you would be picked up and returned to the ship, NO, picked up yes, returned, NO.

Dropped of the full distance away where the other boats pick up and drop off which is the full walking distance,(again,too far for older people-which we are not-& I managed, but I was using a cane due to an injury). We arrived back at the ship 2 days in a row and asked them to send a wheel chair for 2 different people. The days weren’t over yet.

The new “Key” wasn’t what the website described, not totally worth it, most staff doesn’t know what it is and what it covers. NO staff knew where the seating in the theater was. Some excursions were not as described AT ALL. We are typically pretty easy going travelers. We do a lot of our travel planning on our own. We don’t expect a lot. The gathering of passengers in the theater (or wherever) is a “royal” pain.

No excursion left on time. One left 30 minutes late, none of it was because of late clearance, as we had already heard that the ship was cleared and people were cleared to go ashore. It is waiting on late passengers. When we first cruising we went directly to the buses and boarded ourselves. Once the bus was full and the departure time arrived, if everyone wasn’t there the guide would talk to the shore excursions, we would wait 10-15 minutes and go.

People are always late because they know that the excursion will wait for them for such a long time. We don’t go on as many excursions because of this anymore. We can do our own thing, get a taxi and see more and not wait on anyone for the same cost or less. The late people don’t even rush anymore. The ship was tired and the washrooms were not kept up. Two “quiet adult only spaces” were directly below shuffle boards that use plastic pucks. Incredible noisy. It was a wonderfully peaceful place when no one played shuffle board. It could be again if they used the original pucks that are quiet. We typically do not complain but this trip was absolutely terrible.

Honestly, I think most Carnival ships are beautiful (especially the Dream, one of my favorites) However, the picture of the ship chosen was the Valor which is one of the strangest and, in my opinion, ugliest ships in the fleet. The design makes very little sense and the decor is strange and unattractive. I think that was not the best representation for Carnivals ships, just my opinion.

Valor is definitely… unique. That said, even on other Carnival ships that may be a bit more modern there’s still a different feel compared to Royal Caribbean.

When I cruise, I really love live bands. Weather it would be pop, country,or whatever.i enjoy listening and dancing to the music.For me, if I knew that they were having a band, I certainly would be more enticied to choose that particular cruise line, for my cruise.

Justin B – some of those items you mentioned are NOT free. The Windjammer cafeteria is free, and most of the smaller second restaurant (Solarium) is free, but they charge extra for the lobster and (I think) the lamb chops. The drinks here are expensive and they even charge for soda, which I find strange as it’s one of the cheapest things to produce I could go on and on but I will say for those on any type of budget to watch yourself closely with Royal Caribbean and check your bill (for their extra “surprises”) with RC Guest Services. They are absolutely horrible at upwelling and misc nickel and dime charges.

Source—sailed on Ovation of the Seas

Organization the hospitality on Royal is priority, their staff makes sure you are comfortable and well taken care off. It’s a very warming welcome and their cocktails drinks consist with alcohol not juice and ice. Royal Carbbean take good care of their Ship when it come to cleaniness and top of it all well organize especially in the buffet when you dont know when the lines start. Payless dont expect more hospitality is key.

Royal has free burgers hot dogs a fries as well in the huge free buffet called windjammer, also free pizza buffet and more. Symphony of the seas has both plus a mexican food buffet with burritos, tacos, quesadillas, nachos and cheese etc. They also have free ice cream machines. I feel your food comparison is wrong because they have a pretty good selection of free food as well as fancy dining (lobster, steak, fancy desserts etc) that is free every night with a reservation.

you seem to have been on Royal before how about drink package on Royal the one on Carnival isn’t that good as for as for alcohol.

Royal Caribbean allows you to bring non-alcoholic beverages as carry-on items on boarding day. Non-alcoholic beverages may not exceed 12 standard (17 oz.) cans, bottles or cartons per stateroom. Milk and distilled water brought on for infant, medical, or dietary use are permitted.

Thanks for the comment. This is a brand-new policy from the cruise line. We’ll look to update.

Carnival is the same

LEAVE A REPLY Cancel reply

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

12 Cheap Summer Cruises for 2025

18 orlando hotels with shuttles to disney world & universal, new orleans cruise parking (where to park) options, prices, and map, hotels with cruise shuttles for every major port in america, 107 best cruise tips, tricks, secrets, and freebies, 39 useful things to pack for your cruise (including 17 you’d never think of).

• Privacy Policy
• Terms & Conditions

Protect Your Trip »

Royal caribbean vs. carnival: quick comparison chart.

Decide which line is best based on costs, food, onboard entertainment and other key factors.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival

Courtesy of Royal Caribbean International

Royal Caribbean International and Carnival Cruise Line have quite a bit in common.

Trying to choose between Royal Caribbean and Carnival for your next cruise? Check out the comparison chart below, then read on for more details.

Winner: Royal Caribbean

When it comes to fleet size as well as the features available on cruise ships, Royal Caribbean has an edge over Carnival Cruise Line. That's because Royal Caribbean already has 28 ships in operation, including its incredible Oasis Class, Quantum Class and Quantum Ultra Class ships. Oasis Class vessels like Allure of the Seas , Symphony of the Seas , Wonder of the Seas and Utopia of the Seas are some of the largest in the world – and Royal Caribbean Group is constantly rolling out new, even bigger cruise ships with better amenities and new features. For example, the new Icon of the Seas (scheduled to debut in 2024) plans to have the largest water park at sea, the largest swimming pool at sea, and a range of over-the-top cabins and suites for families of all sizes.

Meanwhile, Carnival currently operates 25 different vessels with a few more on the way. Newer ships like Carnival Celebration and Carnival Venezia aren't as large and grand as Royal Caribbean ships, nor are the brand-new vessels the company is planning for late 2023 and 2024. For example, the new Carnival Jubilee that is set to begin sailing later in 2023 will have 15 passenger decks and capacity for up to 6,631 guests, compared to 18 guest decks and 7,600 passengers on Icon of the Seas.

Read: The Largest Cruise Ships in the World

SBW-Photo | Courtesy of Royal Caribbean International

Comparing cabins across cruise lines as a whole isn't an easy feat, mostly because companies tend to offer larger suites and cabins with a better layout on their newer ships . You'll therefore likely have a nicer cabin on one of Carnival's newest vessels compared to an older ship from Royal Caribbean, and of course the opposite is also true. Cabin sizes and layouts also vary widely across the vessels of both brands, and that's true even for basic interior, ocean view and balcony cabins.

That said, Royal Caribbean still comes out ahead in this category, since the line boasts more square footage in some of the most basic cabins as well as more over-the-top luxury accommodations, especially for families.

As an example, most inside cabins on Allure of the Seas feature 172 square feet of space, whereas Carnival Celebration's inside cabins are slightly smaller at 158 square feet. Meanwhile, the largest suites on Celebration are the Carnival Excel Presidential Suite, with 1,120 square feet of space including the balcony, and the Carnival Excel Aft Suite, which has 861 square feet of interior and balcony space. Compare those options to the Sky Loft Suites on Allure of the Seas, which feature 1,132 square feet across the room and balcony, and the spacious two-bedroom AquaTheater Suites with 1,595 square feet including the balcony.

Book a cruise on  GoToSea , a service of U.S. News.

Winner: Tie

Food options vary widely across vessels within any cruise brand, and this is especially true with Royal Caribbean and Carnival. For example, older ships from both cruise lines offer fewer specialty dining options overall along with the main dining rooms and buffet options cruisers come to expect, whereas newer ships from both lines feature a lot more unique and innovative options.

When you view the cruise dining options from both lines, you'll quickly find that both Carnival and Royal Caribbean pull out all the stops when it comes to food. For example, Carnival ships include a range of eateries from large and expansive buffets to main dining rooms to unique offerings like Big Chicken, Guy's Burger Joint and BlueIguana Cantina. Meanwhile, specialty dining on Carnival vessels features options like teppanyaki, Emeril's Bistros at Sea and Guy's Pig & Anchor Smokehouse.

Royal Caribbean ships feature convenient buffets and main dining room experiences, as well as included options like pizza kitchens, noodle bars and casual fast food. Specialty dining on Royal Caribbean ranges from the brand's Chef's Table experience to Johnny Rockets' burgers and shakes to innovative fine dining at Wonderland.

Drink packages

Both Carnival and Royal Caribbean offer drink packages that cruisers can purchase as part of their vacation to get a more all-inclusive feel . Then again, the value of these packages depends on how much you drink over the course of your trip. Also note that the cost of drink packages across all cruise lines can vary depending on the ship, itinerary, travel dates, length of trip and more.

Royal Caribbean comes out slightly ahead in this category because the line offers three tiers of drink packages for guests with different needs. Choose from the Classic Soda Package; the Refreshment Package, which includes soda along with coffees, juices and even milkshakes at Johnny Rockets; and the Deluxe Beverage Package, which adds in beer, cocktails and wine by the glass. Meanwhile, Carnival offers just two different drink packages: the Bottomless Bubbles package, which covers soft drinks and juice, and the Cheers! drink package, which adds in spirits and cocktails, beer, wine by the glass, specialty coffee, energy drinks and more.

Read: Cruise Drink Packages: Your Options by Cruise Line

Onboard activities

Analyzing onboard activities across cruise lines isn't always easy – you really have to break down this category by ship for a true comparison. When you do that with Carnival and Royal Caribbean, you'll find that both lines offer fun activities for all ages, from onboard water parks to hosted games, casinos and more.

That said, Royal Caribbean does take things up a notch in this category, especially on the line's newer ships. Some Royal Caribbean vessels offer escape rooms, surf simulators, zip lines, game shows and over-the-top water parks with incredible slides for thrill-seekers. For example, Freedom of the Seas boasts huge onboard waterslides, glow-in-the-dark laser tag, mini-golf and more. Don't forget about Icon of the Seas with its massive water park and pool offerings in the works. Meanwhile, standout activities on Carnival ships include Family Feud Live, onboard water parks and the thrilling SkyRide.

Compare Royal Caribbean cruises on GoToSea .

Live entertainment

The quality of cruise ship entertainment varies widely based on the quality of the talent booked for individual ships. Both Carnival and Royal Caribbean offer their share of live music and entertainment, including performances by bands and singers, karaoke, and piano bars. Meanwhile, both lines also boast their own theaters on every vessel, which often feature Broadway-style shows, singing and dancing, comedy acts, and more.

Royal Caribbean comes out ahead in this category since its vessels feature award-winning musicals like "Hairspray," "Mamma Mia!" and "Cats." The open-air AquaTheater on Oasis Class ships also wows guests with incredible diving feats, stunts and aerial acrobatics. Some Royal Caribbean ships even have onboard ice skating performances and ice games.

Explore cruise deals on  GoToSea .

Tips on Trips and Expert Picks Newsletter

Travel tips, vacation ideas and more to make your next vacation stellar.

Sign up to receive the latest updates from U.S News & World Report and our trusted partners and sponsors. By clicking submit, you are agreeing to our Terms and Conditions & Privacy Policy .

Kids programming

Courtesy of Carnival Cruise Line

Winner: Carnival

Both cruise lines have kids clubs that cater to younger guests of all ages, with each one offering supervised care so parents can drop the kids off for some alone time or a quiet dinner on the ship. However, Carnival stands out slightly in this category due to the six different clubs offered across the fleet for children and teens between 6 months and 17 years old. Carnival also offers supervised Night Owls services for kids 11 and younger, which lets parents get out and have some late-night fun for an extra charge.

Royal Caribbean offers four kids clubs for children ages six months to 12, along with a separate club for tweens and teens . Supervised child care is available for free during the day, and you can opt for paid care after hours as well.

Read: The Top Cruises for Babies and Toddlers

Adults-only offerings

Both cruise lines offer their share of adults-only spaces and things to do, from onboard casinos to luxurious spas to bars that offer cocktails and live entertainment at all hours of the day and night. Carnival and Royal Caribbean also offer adults-only areas on some of their ships.

On Carnival, for example, cruisers will find the Serenity Adults-Only Retreat for sailors 21 and older with extra space and comfortable chairs for relaxation, along with its own bar nearby. On many Royal Caribbean vessels, on the other hand, the onboard Solarium for ages 16-plus has its own pool and extra space to find peace and quiet.

Carnival's Serenity relaxation area is included for guests. While Royal Caribbean's Solarium is typically also included, on certain sailings there is restricted access by fare class.

Read: The Top Adults-Only Cruises

Shore excursions

Getty Images

Shore excursions offered by cruise lines are largely operated by third-party companies and are often the same across brands. Both Carnival and Royal Caribbean boast a broad selection of excursions in destinations around the world, from snorkeling and scuba tours in the Caribbean to city tours, horseback riding, cooking classes and more.

Both cruise lines offer private and custom tours you can book through your ship as well.

Compare cruises on GoToSea .

Private island experiences

Royal Caribbean and Carnival each have their own private island in the Bahamas , which is included in most itineraries to this part of the world. These private islands provide a fun beach escape for families to enjoy, whether you want to relax in the sun or take part in some of the available activities.

Royal Caribbean's private island, called Perfect Day at CocoCay, is the more impressive option due to everything it includes: a heart-thumping water park, its own wave pool, a zip line, a hot air balloon experience and overwater bungalows you can book for the day, among other offerings. Meanwhile, Carnival's Half Moon Cay has a unique beached pirate ship to explore – but fewer amenities overall.

Note that both private islands have plenty of beach space for guests to spread out and relax, as well as restaurants and bars. You can also book excursions on both private islands, which include activities like snorkeling and water sports.

Read: The Top Cruise Line Private Islands

Comparing costs across cruise lines can be tricky since fares and available sales vary throughout the year, as well as based on the vessel booked, the cruise itinerary, the number and age of travelers, and more. To get an idea of who wins on price, we looked for two similar cruises on comparable ships from Carnival and Royal Caribbean, then priced out an option for a family of four with two children ages 8 and 10. For the purpose of this comparison, we used seven-night eastern Caribbean cruises on Carnival Celebration and Royal Caribbean's Wonder of the Seas, both of which began sailing in 2022.

The Carnival Celebration itinerary from Miami stops in Amber Cove, Dominican Republic; San Juan, Puerto Rico ; and St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands . By comparison, the Wonder of the Seas sailing leaves from Port Canaveral, Florida, with stops in Philipsburg, St. Maarten ; San Juan; and Perfect Day at CocoCay in the Bahamas.

The chart below shows the total cost (including taxes and fees) for a family of four in January 2024 in both an ocean view and a typical balcony cabin across both cruise lines. Note that, for the purpose of this comparison, we selected the least expensive room option in each category.

Read: How Much Does a Cruise Cost?

Why Trust U.S. News Travel

Holly Johnson is a professional travel writer who has covered cruises and other family travel for more than a decade. She has cruised more than 30 times across most of the major cruise lines and has ventured on itineraries around the world. Johnson used her personal experience and research expertise to curate this cruise line comparison.

You might also be interested in:

• Icon of the Seas Review
• The Best Cruise Insurance Plans
• The Top Cruise Lines for Solo Travelers
• How to Find Last-Minute Cruise Deals
• The Top Kids Sail Free Cruises

Tags: Travel , Cruises

World's Best Places To Visit

• # 1 South Island, New Zealand
• # 4 Bora Bora

If you make a purchase from our site, we may earn a commission. This does not affect the quality or independence of our editorial content.

You May Also Like

Top indoor water park resorts.

Holly Johnson and Amanda Norcross Sept. 16, 2024

Adults-Only All-Inclusive Mexico Resorts

Sept. 13, 2024

Romantic Getaways in Texas

Marisa Méndez Sept. 13, 2024

The Best NYC Food Tours

Ann Henson Sept. 12, 2024

The Best Tower of London Tours

Laura French Sept. 11, 2024

Romantic Getaways in Florida

Alissa Grisler and Gwen Pratesi Sept. 9, 2024

The Best Weekend Getaways From NYC

Alissa Grisler and Jessica Colley Clarke Sept. 5, 2024

The Best Beach Resorts in the World

Sept. 5, 2024

The Best Rome Food Tours

Laura Itzkowitz Sept. 4, 2024

Top Things to Do in Hershey, PA

Amanda Norcross Aug. 30, 2024

Royal Caribbean Vs. Carnival: Which Is Best According to Real Cruisers?

• August 2, 2024
• Cruise Ships

Embarking on cruises is one of my favorite ways to vacation. The combination of relaxation, adventure, luxury, and exotic destinations is unbeatable. Regarding major cruise lines, Royal Caribbean and Carnival emerge as the most prominent players. Each of these cruise industry giants promises an unforgettable experience for couples, solo travelers, and families. But which cruise line delivers the best experience?

Over the years, I’ve immersed myself in the world of cruising, dedicating countless hours to understanding what makes each cruise company stand out. In addition to personal experience, I also researched what other cruisers say on review websites like Cruise Critic, TripAdvisor, and Cruiseline.com. This gives me a distinct understanding of the different vibes, amenities, and itineraries you can expect.

In this article, I will share my comprehensive comparison of Royal Caribbean and Carnival—two of the world’s most popular mainstream cruise lines. You’ll discover differences in fixed and flexible dining options, onboard activities, staterooms, cruise itineraries, and more. By the end of the article, you’ll have the information to choose the best line that matches your vacation goals.

Whether you’re planning your first Caribbean cruise or you’re a seasoned cruiser looking for your next adventure, this comparison will help you navigate the unique offerings of these two giants of the sea.

Royal Caribbean Cruise Line: An Overview

Royal Caribbean International (RCI), formed in 1969, is renowned for its vast mega-ships, luxurious amenities, and diverse itineraries to destinations worldwide. It’s one of the world’s largest cruise lines, boasting around 30 ships. The fleet includes the Icon of the Seas, the world’s largest cruise ship, accommodating 7,600 passengers.

With a focus on innovation, Royal Caribbean pushes the boundaries of what cruising can offer. I love the diversity of onboard activities—surf simulators, zip lines, rock climbing, ice skating, bumper cars, and water parks. With itineraries spanning the Caribbean , Europe, and Alaska , Royal Caribbean caters to diverse tastes and preferences.

Highlights of Royal Caribbean Cruises

Royal Caribbean cruise ships consistently impress me with their design and amenities. Many cruisers highlight the impressive size and features of the Icon of the Seas and the comfort and elegance of the Radiance of the Seas. The ships make me feel like I’m on a floating luxurious resort, blending relaxation with adventure.

Dining on Royal Caribbean cruises is an experience I look forward to every trip. I remember enjoying the delicious food at Jamie Oliver’s Italian on Symphony of the Seas. Other culinary highlights include the mouth-watering steaks at Chop’s Grille, the authentic flavors at Giovanni’s Italian Kitchen, and the vibrant, casual bites at El Loco Fresh and Windjammer restaurants.

Other highlights of cruising with Royal Caribbean include:

• Thrilling onboard activities
• Lush indoor spaces mimicking real parks
• Spacious cabins and staterooms
• Live entertainment with Broadway-style shows

Carnival Cruise Line: An Overview

Founded in 1972, Carnival Cruise Line is known for its family-oriented cruises and affordability. This popular cruise line has 27 vessels in its fleet, with the biggest ship—Carnival Jubilee—accommodating 5,374 guests. Carnival has built its reputation as America’s Cruise Line and its “fun ship” concept, with a vibrant onboard atmosphere.

For me, I choose Carnival Cruises because of the lively atmosphere and the unbeatable value. There’s always something happening, from the vibrant poolside parties to the hilarious comedy shows. Yet, I always find the perfect spot to relax and unwind. Also, the affordable cruise fares let me enjoy unforgettable Caribbean vacations without breaking the bank, making Carnival perfect for budget-conscious travelers.

Highlights of Carnival Cruises

Based on my research and discussions with other cruisers, Carnival Cruise Line has consistently delivered some of the most fun and affordable cruising experiences. The vibrant, energetic atmosphere on board is perfect for those looking to mix relaxation with endless entertainment. The ships are not as upscale at Royal Caribbean, but I’m happy with the reasonable cruise fares.

My highlights on Carnival Cruises include the entertainment and fun activities. The comedy shows at the Punchliner Comedy Club are as good as any I’ve seen in New York. Many cruisers rave about the BOLT roller coaster on the Mardi Gras, describing it as a thrilling and unique experience at sea, although I haven’t personally tried it. When it comes to dining, my favorite—and that of most other cruisers—is Guy’s Burger Joint . However, Carnival’s buffet is always outstanding.

Some more of my personal highlights from sailing with Carnival include the following:

• A diverse range of dining options like Emeril’s Bistro, BlueIguana Cantina, and Il Viaggio
• Lively onboard atmosphere with an energetic vibe
• Some of the best waterparks on any cruise ship
• Wide range of entertainment from quizzes to open-air cinemas, musicals and IMAX

Comparison of Royal Caribbean Vs. Carnival Cruise Lines

Choosing between Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Lines can be tricky. As the largest companies in the cruise industry, each boasts around 30 ships, carrying millions of passengers annually to destinations worldwide—the Caribbean, Mexico, Alaska, the Mediterranean, Asia, and the South Pacific Islands.

In this comparison, I’ll put key aspects that significantly impact cruising experiences side-by-side.

Drawing from my experience, extensive research, insights from fellow passengers, and online cruise forums, I’ll highlight key factors that set Royal Caribbean apart from Carnival Cruise. For each section, I’ll provide my conclusions and recommendations.

The main factors I’ll compare are the following:

• Ship size and type of accommodations and cabin options
• Dining experiences
• Onboard activities and entertainment
• Value for money
• Impactful cruise factors—demographics, destinations, and atmosphere

Are you ready to start your voyage of discovery? Imagine navigating through the waves of luxurious innovation on Royal Caribbean or riding the tide of vibrant fun on Carnival. Which cruise line will be your perfect vessel for an unforgettable adventure? Read on to find out.

How the Size of Ships Compare

Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruises have some of the largest cruise vessels in the world. How do the ships compare side-by-side?

Ship size comparison

Royal Caribbean has the largest ships of any cruise line. Its smaller vessels in the Vision and Radiance Class hold around 2,500 passengers. Ships in the Voyager, Freedom, and Quantum average accommodate between 4,000 and 5,000 guests. The biggest cruise ships in the Oasis and Icon Classes have room for 6,800 to 7,600 passengers.

Carnival Cruise Line has nine classes of cruise ships. The smallest vessels in the Fantasy and Spirit Classes have around 2,000 passengers. However, most Carnival cruise ships accommodate 3,000 to 4,200 guests. Its three largest ships in the Excel Class—Mardi Gras, Carnival Celebration, and Carnival Jubilee—each carry 5,282 passengers.

Both cruise lines are similar in fleet size, range of cruise ship classes, and number of guests on board. Of course, Royal Caribbean has the edge in terms of having the largest cruise ship in the world.

Travelers’ insights

How do cruisers rate their cruise experiences? One passenger noted that RC’s Oasis Class ships are like floating cities with something for everyone. In contrast, many guests on Carnival ships love the vibrant, lively, party-like atmosphere. Royal Caribbean’s largest ships, such as the Oasis and Icon Class, are so massive that they are divided into distinct neighborhoods.

My conclusion

• Royal Caribbean ships: Enjoy expansive spaces and state-of-the-art amenities.
• Carnival Cruise Line ships: Friendly, lively atmosphere and plenty of entertainment options.

Comparison of Cabins, Staterooms, and Suites

Choosing the right accommodation can significantly improve your cruise experience. Royal Caribbean and Carnival offer a variety of cabins, staterooms, and suites designed to meet different needs and budgets.

Here’s a definition of the types of accommodations on cruise lines.

• Cabin : The most affordable accommodation option. Cabins without windows are called inside cabins. Cabins with windows or portholes are called outside cabins. They don’t have balconies.
• Stateroom : A mid-range option, including rooms with balconies. They offer more space and amenities than standard cabins.
• Suite : The most luxurious and spacious accommodations, often with separate living areas, enhanced amenities, and exclusive services. Most have balconies.

Accommodations comparison

Royal Caribbean and Carnival offer a range of budget to luxurious accommodations to suit all budgets. Of course, a direct side-by-side comparison is challenging due to the plethora of options.

Royal Caribbean offers a range of elegant and upscale accommodation styles. A unique feature of some inside RC staterooms is the Virtual Balcony—a floor-to-ceiling LED screen with real-time ocean digital views. Royal Caribbean offers Ultimate Family Suites, kid-friendly rooms with play areas, and two-story Royal Loft Suites.

Carnival Cruise Line provides a variety of staterooms and suites to meet different needs. Cove Balcony cabins, located closer to the waterline, offer a unique and intimate balcony experience. Other unique accommodation options include Cloud 9 Spa staterooms, expansive family rooms, and suites with access to a private pool, deck, and adults-only retreat area​.

Comparing the rooms, it’s clear that Royal Caribbean excels with its innovative cabin features and luxurious suite options. In contrast, Carnival focuses on themed cabins, which can be more spacious. Also, access to the Havana areas caters to specific lifestyle preferences, enhancing the cruising experience.

Many passengers highly rate Royal Caribbean for its upscale accommodations, especially rooms with virtual balconies. Cruisers praise Carnival rooms due to their size. The Cloud 9 spa stateroom and Havana cabins receive exceptionally high marks for their unique offerings.

• Royal Caribbean : The best choice for a resort-like experience with upscale rooms.
• Carnival : The largest rooms and cabins in the cruise industry with colorful, bold decor.

What Dining Options Are Available?

The culinary experiences on cruise ships can significantly impact the overall cruise enjoyment. All cruise lines offer all-inclusive food as part of the cruise cost. These offerings are usually buffet-style dining venues offering a range of world cuisine. However, the biggest differences are found in the extra-fee specialty restaurants.

Royal Caribbean has the edge in terms of specialty restaurants and gourmet dining, whereas Carnival has the widest choice of all-inclusive offerings.

Dining options comparison

Royal Caribbean provides a diverse array of dining options, from casual buffets to upscale specialty restaurants. Highlights include Jamie Oliver’s Italian, Chops Grille Steakhouse, Izumi Asian-inspired dining menu, and the Wonderland restaurant—a whimsical, avant-garde dining experience. The Windjammer Buffet and the Main Dining Room (MDR) are the primary free dining venues. You can also choose from bistros, cafes, noodles, and Mexican cuisine.

Carnival Cruise Line focuses on fun, accessible dining with various options. It provides some of the best free specialty restaurants on any cruise ship. These include Guy’s Burger Joint, BlueIguana Cantina for Mexican dishes, Shaq’s Big Chicken, Pizzeria del Capitano, Lucky Bowl, and Chibang. Also, The main dining rooms and buffet provide ample choices.

Carnival excels in the range of dining options included in the cruise price. This is also one of the reasons why I find Carnival cruises so affordable. In fact, on a Carnival ship, I rarely opt for their specialty dining options as I’m spoiled for choice elsewhere. On the contrary, Royal Caribbean focuses on a more upscale dining experience in its specialty restaurants.

Travelers often rave about Royal Caribbean’s Windjammer restaurant for its high-quality food and themed nights. However, others criticize it for long lines and less attentive service compared to the main dining restaurant. Most Carnival guests say the ships have the best casual food options, with big names like celebrity Food Network chef Guy Fieri and Shaquille O’Neal.

• Royal Caribbean : An excellent choice if you are willing to pay for its upscale specialty restaurants that offer gourmet experiences.
• Carnival : Celebrated for its fun and casual dining atmosphere, with popular venues like Guy’s Burger Joint and BlueIguana Cantina providing delicious meals at no extra cost.  

Comparing Onboard Activities and Entertainment

For many cruise enthusiasts, onboard activities and entertainment options are pivotal to the overall experience. These are not afterthoughts—they’re a core part of what makes a cruise vacation memorable and enjoyable. Onboard activities include everything from swimming to mini-golf and water slides. Entertainment includes Broadway musicals, cabaret, and comedy clubs.

Many cruisers say that Carnival excels at providing a fun-filled sea vacation for people of all ages. The vibe on board is more relaxed and vibrant. On the other hand, I’ve enjoyed some of the most unique activities on Royal Caribbean cruises. Where else could you go zip lining, ice skating, and surfing while at sea?

Activities and entertainment comparison

Royal Caribbean is renowned for its extensive and innovative onboard activities. The fleet features groundbreaking activities like the FlowRider surf simulators, zip lines, rock climbing walls, ice skating rinks, bumper cars, and indoor skydiving. Newer vessels, like Quantum-class ships such as Anthem of the Seas, Ovation of the Seas, and Spectrum of the Seas, offer unique experiences, such as the SeaPlex, with roller skating and trapeze classes.

Royal Caribbean also excels in entertainment with Broadway-style shows, acrobatic performances at the AquaTheater, and ice skating shows.​ Book your place to see shows like “Cats,” “Hairspray,” “Grease,” or “Mamma Mia.”

Carnival Cruise Line focuses on fun, family-friendly activities. Highlights include the WaterWorks water park, outdoor sports centers with mini golf and basketball, and the SkyRide aerial bike ride. Newer ships like the Mardi Gras feature the superb BOLT roller coaster.

Cruisers love the diverse entertainment options Carnival has on their ships. These include comedy sets, live music, and poolside movies, ensuring there’s always something exciting happening​. Taking part in popular shows like Family Feud is especially fun for families and groups.

Travelers’ Insights

In my experience, Royal Caribbean ships offer such a wide range of activities and amenities that they feel like destinations in their own right. Many cruisers seem to agree, often highlighting the sheer variety of entertainment and dining options available onboard.

One cruiser mentioned, “The FlowRider and rock climbing walls kept us entertained all day, while the Broadway-style shows were out of this world.” Meanwhile, Carnival cruisers love the lively atmosphere. A passenger shared, “The WaterWorks park was a hit with the kids, and the comedy shows were hilarious.”​

• Royal Caribbean : I enjoyed some of the most entertaining shows and fun activities on any cruise ship I’ve been on.
• Carnival : Perfect for fun, family-friendly activities, and accessible entertainment with a plethora of choices from singers to dancers, comedians, and live music

How Do Cruise Ship Features Stack Up?

When choosing between Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line, it’s essential to understand how their onboard features compare. Having experienced both lines, I’ve noticed that each has distinctive characteristics catering to different preferences. These unique features ensure every passenger, including myself, has a memorable cruise experience tailored to their interests and needs.

Kids’ Clubs

Royal Caribbean : Adventure Ocean offers age-specific activities, from science labs to themed play areas. Other dads told me their kids love the interactive sessions and the dedicated teen lounge.

Carnival Cruise Line : Camp Ocean features marine-themed activities, whereas Dr. Seuss-themed activities are a hit with younger children. I also heard a great buzz on board from parents whose teenagers enjoyed dance parties and games at the Circle “C” club.

• Recommendation : Carnival Cruise Line has the best onboard clubs for entertaining and educating kids from age 2 to teens.

Poolside Facilities

Royal Caribbean: Most ships have multiple pools, combining fun and relaxation. I enjoyed the adults-only areas for unwinding and reading a book. The H2O Zone water park and splash pools are a hit with kids. Personally, I haven’t had the chance to try the FlowRider surf simulator and the Typhoon and Cyclone slides, but many cruisers rave about these features, describing them as exhilarating and unique. Additionally, many recommend trying RipCord by iFLY, an indoor skydiving simulator, for a thrilling experience.

Carnival Cruise Line : WaterWorks water park has thrilling slides for people of all ages. The main pools are always lively, with poolside games and DJ music creating a fun atmosphere. A ride on the BOLT on the Mardi Gras was a unique thrill.

• Recommendation : Royal Caribbean wins the pool competition, especially on the newer, larger ships. They have the largest water park at sea with adrenaline-pumping water slides.

Adults-Only Spaces

Royal Caribbean : The Solarium is a serene, adults-only retreat with whirlpools, padded loungers, and peaceful surroundings. Cruisers love the front-side views, tranquil atmosphere, and glass-covered top as I relaxed on a sun lounger.

Carnival Cruise Line : Provides the Serenity Adult-Only Retreat, featuring comfortable loungers, pool, hammocks, and bar service. The tranquility of the Serenity area was a welcome escape from the bustling activities elsewhere on the ship.

• Recommendation : Comparing the two cruise lines, I preferred the Solarium due to its lagoon-like feel and fantastic 270° views.

High-Tech Amenities

Royal Caribbean : Have you ever had robots mix your drinks? Enjoying a Caribbean cocktail in the Bionic Bar is one of the coolest experiences I’ve had at sea. Also, the North Star observation capsule provides 360° views as it takes you 300 ft. (91 m) above sea level. One of the most innovative features on Royal Caribbean ships is the virtual balconies in inside cabins—these were a real game-changer for me to save money on a luxury cruise.

Carnival Cruise Line : Incorporates fun tech with the Carnival HUB app, which is ideal for managing daily activities on board. One of the unique features is the SkyRide aerial bike ride, which offers fantastic views and a workout at the same time.

• Recommendation : Royal Caribbean wins the battle of high-tech amenities with its virtual balconies and Bionic Bar.

Royal Caribbean Vs. Carnival: Destinations and Itineraries

Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean are unrivaled in the cruise industry in terms of the number of destinations they visit. Both have a strong presence in the most popular cruise destinations in North America, including Alaska . Cruise ship home ports also affect prices, destinations, and itineraries.

Destination and itinerary comparison

Royal Caribbean offers one of the most extensive ranges of destinations in the cruise industry. According to its website, cruise itineraries include over 270 destinations in over 60 countries on six continents. Ports of call include the Caribbean, Mexico, Alaska, and Europe. You can also find cruises in European countries, the Mediterranean, the British Isles, Asia, the South Pacific, Australia, and New Zealand.

Carnival Cruise Line focuses on destinations in North American departures, with home ports across the U.S., including Florida, California, and Texas. Carnival’s itineraries mainly cover the Caribbean, the Bahamas , Alaska, and Mexico . They also have some sailings to Europe , the South Pacific, Asia, and Australia.

Overall, Royal Caribbean offers broader itineraries and destinations ideal for global adventures.

Many travelers book with Royal Caribbean for a more upmarket experience and their diverse itineraries in far-flung destinations. However, Carnival is the choice for people living in North America due to the number of home ports and extensive itineraries in the Caribbean.

• Royal Caribbean : Best for travelers seeking diverse, exotic destinations, including extensive European itineraries and unique global adventures.
• Carnival : Ideal for convenient North American departures, good value for money, and vibrant Caribbean cruises.

Private Island Experiences

Some of my favorite destinations cruising with Royal Caribbean and Carnival are their private island experiences. These exclusive cruise destinations in the Bahamas provide a taste of paradise and an unforgettable adventure. I also love that there are no pesky vendors on the beaches trying to sell their wares.

Private island comparison

Royal Caribbean: Perfect Day at CocoCay:

Royal Caribbean’s private island—Perfect Day at CocoCay—is a stunning destination on Bahamian cruises. Here, you enjoy a mix of relaxation and adventure. Features of CocoCay include the following attractions:

• Daredevil’s Peak, the tallest waterslide in North America
• The Caribbean’s biggest wave pool and largest freshwater pool in the Bahamas
• Swim-up bar
• Helium balloon rides
• Various water and beach sports
• Private cabanas
• Several dining options

Carnival: Half Moon Cay

Carnival’s Half Moon Cay is a private, uninhabited island in the Bahamas, offering a serene beach experience. Plenty of activities also give passengers a memorable experience on shore. Here are some of the attractions of Half Moon Cay:

• Horseback riding on the beach
• Interacting with stingrays at Stingray Cove
• Snorkeling tours to explore vibrant coral reefs
• Pirate-themed water park for kids
• Private cabanas and private villas for rent

The main difference I found between the two islands is the type of experience. Royal Caribbean has pulled out all the stops on Perfect Day at CocoCay, which features high-adrenaline activities and luxurious amenities. In contrast, Carnival’s Half Moon Cay offers a more laid-back, nature-focused experience.

Most comments on cruise forums mirror my experiences of the islands. For example, one traveler mentioned CocoCay, saying, “The water slides and zip line were thrilling, and the floating cabanas added a touch of luxury.” Meanwhile, Carnival guests appreciate Half Moon Cay’s natural beauty and relaxed atmosphere. A passenger shared, “Horseback riding on the beach was a unique and unforgettable experience.”

• Royal Caribbean : For a thrilling mix of high-energy activities and luxury, Perfect Day at CocoCay is unbeatable. The waterslides, zip lines, and floating cabanas made my day unforgettable.
• Carnival : Half Moon Cay is ideal if you seek serenity and nature-focused fun. I loved the tranquil beaches, stingray experience, and family-friendly vibe. 

Comparison of Pricing and Value

Comparing like-for-likes with Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line is tricky because of many factors. For example, ship size, season, cabin types, promotional deals, and dates affect pricing. However, Carnival and Royal Caribbean generally compete in the same space, unlike luxury cruise lines like Regent Seven Seas and Seabourn.

Pricing and value for money comparison

Royal Caribbean offers a broad range of pricing, often reflecting the extensive amenities, upscale amenities, and innovative features. I’ve generally found RC cruises to be $100 to $200 more expensive than a similar Carnival cruise. Also, you may find that basic Royal Caribbean fares don’t include as many extras as Carnival.

However, if you’re prepared to pay a bit more, Royal Caribbean cruises offer a more upscale experience, extensive dining options, and classy entertainment. I’ve also found that Royal Caribbean suites are only slightly more expensive than Carnival but offer better value for money.

Carnival Cruise Line is known for its affordability, making it a popular choice for budget-conscious cruise-goers . Like-for-like cruises are generally priced lower, and the inclusive dining options offer substantial value. Carnival’s drink packages are cheaper, though they limit alcoholic drinks to 15 per day . Carnival also runs frequent promotions, allowing for additional savings on basic cruise fares, drink packages, and onboard activities.

Based on my own experience and the opinion of most cruise passengers, the price point of Carnival cruises is hard to beat. So, it all comes down to the type of cruise experience you want.

One guest remarked, “Royal Caribbean’s ships offer so much for the price, especially with the high-end dining and unique activities.” Conversely, Carnival cruisers often highlight the excellent value for money. A frequent cruiser noted, “Carnival’s affordable prices and extensive included options make it easy to have a great time without overspending.”

• Royal Caribbean : As someone who loves a touch of luxury, I find Royal Caribbean perfect for indulging in its upscale amenities and diverse dining.
• Carnival : Ideal for budget-conscious travelers and families looking for excellent value, inclusive dining, and a fun, lively atmosphere.

Passenger Demographics and Atmosphere

Passenger demographics and onboard atmosphere greatly influence my choice of cruises. For a relaxed, more upscale experience with excellent dining options, I tend to choose Royal Caribbean. However, when traveling with friends, I prefer Carnival when we want fun on board.

Here are my opinions of what you can expect onboard regarding fellow passengers and the atmosphere.

Demographics comparison

Royal Caribbean attracts a diverse range of passengers, from families and couples to solo travelers and groups of friends. The atmosphere on board is generally upscale, offering a blend of adventure and luxury. However, there’s a good mix of relaxation and excitement, suitable for those looking for energetic activities and serene getaways​​.

Carnival Cruise Line is known for its lively and casual atmosphere. It attracts a lot of families, younger travelers, and budget-conscious cruisers. The ships can get crowded during school holidays and spring break. I’ve found that the ambiance is festive and fun, with plenty of entertainment, poolside games, and themed parties.

Both cruise lines attract a similar crowd, with Carnival Cruises having a slightly younger demographic and more kids.

Passengers often praise Royal Caribbean for its refined atmosphere and diverse international crowd. One traveler mentioned, “The upscale feel and variety of activities on Royal Caribbean ships make for a luxurious experience.” On the other hand, Carnival cruisers appreciate the energetic and social environment. One passenger observed, “Most of the cruisers on Carnival ships are young, love to party, and quite exuberant, yet many senior citizens love the line for just that reason.”

Interestingly, most passengers who compare Royal Caribbean and Carnival say that Carnival’s three to four-day cruises are the ones attracting party crowds. There is usually little difference in demographics and atmosphere on seven to ten-day cruises.

• Royal Caribbean : Best for couples and solo travelers seeking an elegant, diverse, and upscale cruising experience with a mix of relaxation and adventure.
• Carnival : Ideal for those who prefer a lively, casual, and social atmosphere, perfect for families, younger travelers, and budget-conscious cruisers. 

Which Cruise Line is Best for Families?

The consensus is that Carnival is best for families due to its affordable pricing, extensive kids’ programs, and fun activities like WaterWorks and SkyRide. The vibrant atmosphere and family-friendly dining options make it ideal for a memorable family vacation. It’s also suitable for cruising on a budget, especially when traveling with children.

Which Cruise Line is Best for Couples or Adults?

Most cruise forums like Cruise Critic and Cruise Hive recommend Royal Caribbean for couples, adults, and solo travelers seeking a more upscale experience. It offers excellent amenities, elegant dining, and adult-only spaces like the Solarium. The sophisticated atmosphere and diverse activities ensure a romantic and relaxing getaway.

What About Accessibility on Royal Caribbean and Carnival?

Cruising should be accessible and enjoyable for everyone, regardless of mobility or special needs. Royal Caribbean and Carnival have taken significant steps to ensure their ships cater to all. For example, both cruise lines have wheelchair-accessible balconies on their newer ships.

Let’s see how Royal Caribbean and Carnival compare regarding accessible features on their ships.

Accessibility comparison

Royal Caribbean impresses with its comprehensive accessibility features. Their accessible staterooms, with wider doorways, roll-in showers, and grab bars, make cruising comfortable. I was particularly impressed by their services for visually impaired guests with Qualified Readers available. Also, Perfect Day at CocoCay is an accessible island with wheelchair-friendly beach access.

The cruise line has policies to cater to guests—including children—with autism, cognitive disabilities, or increased oxygen requirements.

Carnival Cruise Line

Carnival Cruise Line ships have excellent accessibility for passengers with disabilities. Elevators, certain staterooms, all dining venues, and pools have wheelchair access. Also, their Youth Programs cater to children with various disabilities, including autism, down syndrome, and ADHA.

Traveler’s Insights

Travelers like me often commend Royal Caribbean for its accessible amenities and services. One guest mentioned, “The accessible staterooms and helpful staff made our cruise comfortable and enjoyable.” Similarly, Carnival’s inclusive environment wins praise. A fellow passenger shared, “Carnival’s accessibility features and friendly assistance ensured we had a fantastic trip.”

Comparing Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival: Beyond Destinations and Amenities

When deciding between Royal Caribbean and Carnival, it’s essential to consider factors beyond destinations and amenities. Customer service, and loyalty programs significantly shape your cruise experience. Here’s how the two cruise lines compare in these areas.

Customer Service and Satisfaction

Royal Caribbean is known for its exceptional customer service, with staff frequently praised for their professionalism and attentiveness. A customer service value report found that “ RCI successfully executes a customer value strategy and outperforms key rivals. ”

Carnival also boasts friendly and helpful staff, often noted for creating a fun and welcoming atmosphere. However, when analyzing general comments in forums and online discussion groups, Carnival falls behind Royal Caribbean in terms of customer satisfaction.

Loyalty Programs and Rewards

How do Royal Caribbean and Carnival loyalty programs compare in terms of value? Here’s what I’ve discovered about each line.

Royal Caribbean’s Crown & Anchor Society offers a tiered system with increasing benefits the more you cruise. Perks include priority boarding, exclusive events, and discounts. The program is highly praised for its comprehensive rewards, which enhance the cruising experience significantly as you climb the ranks, making frequent cruisers feel valued and appreciated.

Carnival’s VIFP Club (Very Important Fun Person) also offers tiered benefits based on the number of days cruised. Benefits include priority check-in, complimentary gifts, and members-only parties. While the VIFP Club provides good value, frequent cruisers feel the rewards are less generous than Royal Caribbean’s offerings, especially at higher tiers.

Personal Experiences and Expertise

In my opinion, Royal Caribbean offers a more luxurious and innovative cruise experience. I loved the top-notch dining, high-tech amenities, wide range of facilities, and diverse itineraries. Carnival provides a more fun, budget-friendly option with lively entertainment and the best flexible dining options.

Here is a selection of guest comments from those who shared their unbiased opinions on Reddit and Quora. I’ve shared these as they reflect my experiences.

Dining options: “The Windjammer buffet on Royal has better options than Carnival’s buffet.” However, one guest said about Carnival, “Carnival offers better complimentary options outside the buffet, like Guy’s Burgers and Shaq’s Big Chicken.”

Onboard entertainment: “Royal’s shows are more appealing and incorporate more technology, making for a more visual experience.” In contrast, “Carnival emphasizes fun games and activities organized by the staff, which are interactive and great for meeting new people.”

Value for Money: “ Royal has noticeable upcharges and fewer free-dining options. However, the drink package is excellent value for money.” On the other hand, “Carnival is generally lower priced and has more complimentary options, providing better bang for your buck.”

In Conclusion

In conclusion, Royal Caribbean and Carnival offer unique cruising experiences catering to different preferences. For a lively, party-centered atmosphere, Carnival is ideal. However, if you seek a more balanced experience with diverse activities, I thoroughly recommend Royal Caribbean. Consider your priorities and budget, choose accordingly, and I wish you an unforgettable adventure on your next cruise.

Related articles:

• Finding Cheap Cruises: Tips and Tricks from Experienced Cruisers
• The Best Luxury Small Cruise Ships at Sea
• Reasons Savvy Cruisers Stay Onboard During Port Days

Adam Stewart

Adam Stewart is the founder of Cruise Galore. He is a passionate traveler who loves cruising. Adam's goal is to enhance your cruising adventures with practical tips and insightful advice, making each of your journeys unforgettable.

Leave a Reply Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Name  *

Email  *

Add Comment  *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Post Comment

• Credit cards
• View all credit cards
• Banking guide
• Loans guide
• Insurance guide
• Personal finance
• View all personal finance
• Small business
• Small business guide
• View all taxes

You’re our first priority. Every time.

We believe everyone should be able to make financial decisions with confidence. And while our site doesn’t feature every company or financial product available on the market, we’re proud that the guidance we offer, the information we provide and the tools we create are objective, independent, straightforward — and free.

So how do we make money? Our partners compensate us. This may influence which products we review and write about (and where those products appear on the site), but it in no way affects our recommendations or advice, which are grounded in thousands of hours of research. Our partners cannot pay us to guarantee favorable reviews of their products or services. Here is a list of our partners .

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival: Which Is Right For You?

Many or all of the products on this page are from partners who compensate us when you click to or take an action on their website, but this does not influence our evaluations or ratings. Our opinions are our own.

Table of Contents

Fleet size and type

Onboard activities, family atmosphere, destination availability, loyalty program, carnival vs. royal caribbean recapped.

Both frequent and first-time cruisers are sure to recognize brands like Royal Caribbean or Carnival. As two popular cruise lines in the U.S., both have plenty to offer passengers who are looking for sun, fun and adventure.

But which is better, Carnival or Royal Caribbean? Or is there much of a difference? The answer lies in where you want to go and the kind of experience you want to have.

Depending on what you’re looking for in a cruise vacation, the Carnival Cruise versus Royal Caribbean debate has fans on both sides of the aisle (or should we say pier).

Here’s a thorough comparison so you can decide between Royal Caribbean or Carnival.

Winner: Royal Caribbean

Both cruise lines have many ships in varying sizes, including several new and elaborate ships. Both companies are market leaders in terms of fleet sizes.

That said, Royal Caribbean has more ships and they’re often larger, which means additional dining, activities and lodging options for passengers.

Royal Caribbean's fleet

Royal Caribbean has 27 ships, with more on the way. While ship size isn't always a deciding factor on which is better, Royal Caribbean tends to have larger ships with flashier amenities. In fact, Royal Caribbean has five of the largest passenger ships in the world based on gross tonnage and passenger capacity.

Its largest ship at the moment, Wonder of the Seas, weighs 235,600 gross tons and can carry more than 9,000 passengers and crew members. Its oldest ship is the Grandeur of the Seas, which launched in 1996. Its ships range from accommodating 2,400 up to nearly 7,000 guests.

Carnival's fleet

Carnival has 23 ships in its fleet with more on order. Its oldest ship is Carnival Sunshine, which made its first sailing in 1996.

Its ships range in size, hosting around 2,100 to 5,200 guests. Carnival Celebration is the line’s largest and newest ship with a gross tonnage of about 180,000 tons and space for over 5,200 passengers. 

» Learn more: How much does a cruise to the Bahamas cost?

Winner: Carnival

This is hard to compare because the cost varies depending on the date you’re traveling and where you’re going to. Like airlines and hotels, demand can vary, which means the price does, too.

Other factors that can influence price are holiday periods, cabin type and advance purchase time. 

In general, both lines compete in the same space. While other cruise lines like Seabourn, Regent Seven Seas and Silversea may specifically target the upscale sector, both Carnival and Royal Caribbean offer a wide range of price points.  

Royal Caribbean pricing

Given the wide range of cabin types, including high-end suites and typically more elaborate decor, it’s not uncommon to see higher prices with Royal Caribbean. 

When searching for a three-night Bahamas cruise departing from Miami in August 2023, Royal Caribbean is offering a cruise for $403 per person for an interior cabin, not including taxes or fees. A suite will run you $609 before taxes and fees.

This price point is higher than Carnival for the interior cabin, but lower for the suite.

Carnival pricing

When it comes to Carnival or Royal Caribbean, the prices hover in the same range — although on many dates and itineraries, Carnival tends to underprice Royal Caribbean.

For a three-night Bahamas cruise, also departing from Miami in August 2023, Carnival has interior rooms starting at $274 per person before taxes and fees. A suite costs $786 per person before taxes and fees.

» Learn more: Are cruises all-inclusive?

Both lines offer a range of accommodations, from inside cabins to top-notch suites with luxurious extras.

This category would otherwise be a tie were it not for some of the unique features that Royal Caribbean has added on its newer ships on both ends of the pricing scale.

Royal Caribbean cabins

In the interior cabins of its newer ships, Royal Caribbean has added real-time, virtual balconies that provide the sensation of having an actual balcony (without the breeze or temperature, of course). This is a unique way to balance price with experience, but of course, nothing can replace a real balcony.

On the high end, some of its newest family suites have in-room slides and game rooms spread across two floors. 

Carnival cabins

Like its competitor, the cruise line has something for every budget. It doesn’t have the same bells and whistles as Royal Caribbean offers, though.

» Learn more: Is cruise travel insurance worth the cost?

Both lines offer plenty to keep you busy without ever needing to leave the ship. These include a daily itinerary of events from contests, game shows, live entertainment and casino specials.

While not every ship has every type of amenity, both lines do an excellent job of creating variety. Royal Caribbean wins this category because of its additional and unique activity offerings.

Royal Caribbean's onboard activities

What gives this line the win in this category is that it has special amenities that others don’t — like the FlowRider surf simulator, where guests can try their hand at a free surf lesson.

Simulated skydiving, ice skating, trapeze lessons, escape rooms and rock climbing walls add to the fun. Don’t miss the SeaPlex, which has plenty of indoor activities like roller skating, basketball courts and bumper cars.

Royal Caribbean is one of the largest producers of live entertainment. Each year, it runs more than 13,000 performances, surpassing Broadway and London’s West End combined. This includes those conducted in or under the water at the cruise line’s AquaTheater, specifically built for aqua acrobatics in the world’s deepest pool at sea.

You’ll also find the world’s tallest viewing deck on a cruise ship, according to Guinness World Records.

Carnival's onboard activities

The family-style activities on this line range from pools with waterslides and kids’ clubs to playgrounds, ropes courses, mini golf and basketball courts.

Carnival also has plenty of evening entertainment from musical productions and Broadway-style shows to headlining entertainers and comedians. There are game shows, like Family Feud, that guests can be a part of for added fun.

The Carnival Mardi Gras and Celebration ships offer rides on the first roller coaster at sea, and three ships have the SkyRide (aerial biking).

If you’re sailing with the family, both cruise lines offer kids' programs, swimming pools and waterslides. Also, both have private islands in the Bahamas with pools and water parks.

On board, the mix of other passengers can determine the overall experience, but both cruise companies do an excellent job of offering fun for all ages. Carnival wins this category for its more laid-back atmosphere and the number of children-specific activities.

Royal Caribbean for families

Perfect Day Island at CocoCay is Royal Caribbean’s expansive private island with water activities, dining areas and plenty of beach. It also has the region’s largest wave and resort pools.

Back on board, young guests can explore the adventure science lab or a 3D puppet show.

Royal Caribbean has so much that knocks it out of the water on the unique onboard amenity front, but most activities are geared toward all ages. When it comes to youth-oriented variety, it generally offers a bit less.

Carnival for families

Half Moon Cay is Carnival’s private island with horseback riding in the sea, a mock pirate ship, water activities, villas to rent and a coastline with lounge chairs.

The Seuss at Sea program offers fun for young travelers, including costume parties and themed breakfasts with their favorite Dr. Seuss characters. Even the spa has treatments for teenagers seeking a little pampering.

There’s also a NASA-inspired space program for kids, an IMAX theater and a thrill theater that simulates being on hair-raising roller coasters.

» Learn more: Family vacation planning tips I learned on the fly

Winner: Tie

Both cruise lines offer excellent dining options that span a global palate profile, but if you’re looking for specialty dining, Royal Caribbean has more options.

Still, if you’re looking for variety, it’s hard to tip the scale in favor of either brand — although Carnival deserves props for offering more well-known food options without an extra fee.

Royal Caribbean food

It's hard to go hungry on a Royal Caribbean ship because of its numerous dining options and specialty dining choices. One area where it falls short is name recognition, with fewer celebrity chefs lending their brand to its onboard eateries. Jamie Oliver is one, and a familiar favorite is Johnny Rockets. Carnival still has more specialty venues.

Carnival Cruise food

This brand is well-known for its tasty food and celebrity partnerships with names like Guy Fieri and Emeril Lagasse.

If the names mean nothing, the brand may still resonate, with partnerships like Guy’s Burger Joint and Guy’s Pig & Anchor Smokehouse. Many of these celebrity chef and specialty dining venues are complimentary, unlike those on Royal Caribbean.

Both lines deploy their fleets on substantial itineraries in many parts of the world. Interesting options include both the Panama Canal and trans-Atlantic crossings.

Royal Caribbean itineraries

The route map for Royal Caribbean ships is widespread, covering the Caribbean, Mexico, Alaska, Hawaii, Europe and Australia, among other places.

It has a large number of North American departure points. The line even offers a South Pacific sailing that visits places like Vanuatu and New Caledonia.

Carnival itineraries

Carnival does a lot of Caribbean and Mexico itineraries from more than a dozen North American ports of call. It also sails around the world, including to eclectic places like Papua New Guinea and Greenland.

» Learn more: The best credit cards for family travel

Both cruise lines offer plenty to do after the sun sets — from live entertainment and karaoke to dance clubs and comedy hours. But Royal Caribbean has a greater number of head-turning evening activities to please night owls.

Royal Caribbean nightlife

From sublime jazz club vibes to thumping nightclub venues, Royal Caribbean offers several options for after-dark entertainment.

Among its offerings are Playmakers Bar & Arcade, which pairs drinks with arcade games, and Boleros, a Latin-themed nightclub with music, dance and cocktails. Most spectacularly, many ships have robotic bartenders that can prepare special cocktails at the touch of a button and a bar that levitates within the inside of the ship.

Carnival nightlife

Live music is available in many venues, but it’s the DJs in the nightclub that keep things busy late into the night.

There are also piano bars and spots to take free dance lessons. Havana Bar mixes in some Cuban flavor to cocktail hour while the tiki bar switches the theme to a South Pacific atmosphere.

Overall, however, the after-hours entertainment just seems less flashy and sophisticated.

» Learn more: 6 cruises where you don’t need a passport

Both lines offer loyalty programs with substantial perks depending on your status level. Those who aren't members of the program can still opt to pay extra for those perks.

Still, it’s better if you get perks for free as part of the loyalty program. In this realm, Royal Caribbean wins — it has a reciprocal partnership with sibling companies like Celebrity that can increase the benefit opportunity.

Royal Caribbean loyalty program

Special onboard events, discounts and benefits are available for members of Royal Caribbean’s loyalty program, the Crown & Anchor Society. The number of perks rises based on the status you hold.

Members earn status by sailing often with Royal Caribbean. The program also offers a status match if you have elite status on Celebrity cruises, making it easier to attain status.

Using the Royal Caribbean Visa Signature Credit Card can also help members inch closer to a free cruise or onboard discounts via the points they earn.

Carnival loyalty program

Carnival’s loyalty program — cleverly dubbed the Very Important Fun Person Club, or the VIFP Club — operates in a similar manner. The more points you earn and the more often you cruise, the more perks you get.

A great way to earn points is with The Carnival World Mastercard , but with few non-cruise perks, it’s not the best option to use when making other purchases.

VIFP Club’s scale is smaller, since it doesn't provide reciprocal perks on other sibling brands. This is an immediate drawback when comparing the two, but it still makes sense to join the program if you sail often with Carnival.

Is Royal Caribbean or Carnival better? Assuming both cruise lines can fit your date, destination and amenity preferences, Royal Caribbean comes out ahead. This is particularly true if your budget can accommodate the higher cost for interior cabins and/or you aren’t traveling with kids. 

Meanwhile, more price-sensitive solo/couple travelers may prefer Carnival. It offers ample specialty dining and activity options, not to mention a good experience at a generally cheaper price point. While suites are more expensive for traveling families, the entertainment available to young cruisers is hard to beat.

How to maximize your rewards

You want a travel credit card that prioritizes what’s important to you. Here are some of the best travel credit cards of 2024 :

Flexibility, point transfers and a large bonus: Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card

No annual fee: Wells Fargo Autograph℠ Card

Flat-rate travel rewards: Capital One Venture Rewards Credit Card

Bonus travel rewards and high-end perks: Chase Sapphire Reserve®

Luxury perks: The Platinum Card® from American Express

Business travelers: Ink Business Preferred® Credit Card

on Chase's website

1x-5x 5x on travel purchased through Chase Travel℠, 3x on dining, select streaming services and online groceries, 2x on all other travel purchases, 1x on all other purchases.

60,000 Earn 60,000 bonus points after you spend $4,000 on purchases in the first 3 months from account opening. That's $750 when you redeem through Chase Travel℠.

on Bank of America's website

1.5x-2x Earn unlimited 2 points for every $1 spent on travel and dining purchases and unlimited 1.5 points for every $1 spent on all other purchases.

60,000 Receive 60,000 online bonus points - a $600 value - after you make at least $4,000 in purchases in the first 90 days of account opening.

• Visit Family Vacation Critic on Facebook!
• Visit Family Vacation Critic on Twitter!
• Visit Family Vacation Critic on Instagram!
• 1 Subscribe to stay up to date!
• Cruises for Families

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival: Which Cruise Line Is Right for Your Family?

Jan 22, 2020

See recent posts by Cortney Fries

You know you want to go on a cruise for your next family vacation, but how do you choose between some of the most popular cruise lines for families ? Carnival and Royal Caribbean are two power players in family cruising , with a plethora of unique activities both on and off the ships. Based on our family’s recent experiences on Carnival Panorama, Royal Caribbean’s Symphony of the Seas and Royal Caribbean’s Navigator of the Seas, as well some industry expertise, we’ve compared Carnival vs. Royal Caribbean to help you choose the right cruise line for your next vacation.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival: Cost

Royal Caribbean:  “Royal Caribbean’s fares— especially on newer ships—tend to be a bit higher, but with a greater selection of options onboard, some at an added cost (such as room service and specialty dining),” says Erica Silverstein, senior editor at Cruise Critic .

Carnival: Known to be affordable, casual and focused on fun, Carnival was recently named Best Cruise Line for Value by the editors of Cruise Critic. Silverstein says this is due in large part to their budget-friendly fares and wealth of inclusions.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival: Kids’ Programs

Royal Caribbean:  Adventure Ocean is Royal Caribbean’s complimentary youth program for ages 3 to 17. Its edu-tainment features programs in art, theater and science. Teens will love socializing in their own spaces, including a teen-only lounge and nightclub. Arcades and 3D theaters bring the action to life and create additional opportunities for tweens and teens to meet new friends.

Cruising with an infant? Order organic baby food , diapers , wipes and other essentials via Babies 2 Go , to be delivered to your stateroom upon arrival.

Late-night group babysitting ensures kids are cared for in the comfort of their staterooms while parents enjoy an evening out. “Royal Caribbean also has a drop-off, extra-fee nursery and free parent-kid play space for under-3s on many ships,” says Silverstein.

Carnival:  Carnival offers Camp Ocean for children aged 2 to 11, where they enjoy games, crafts, music and more in groups divided by age (Penguins: 2 to 5; Stingrays: 6 to 8; and Sharks: 9 to 11). “Carnival is the only line in the industry to allow 2-year-olds to be dropped off at its programs,” says Silverstein. “Counselors will also change diapers.” For tweens and teens, there’s Club O2, with karaoke, sports and even a prom !

Night Owls programming offers nighttime babysitting for an added fee.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival: Family Activities and Entertainment

Royal Caribbean: Royal Caribbean is an adventure in technology and entertainment. The line offers huge ships with amusement park-like amenities — including many industry firsts — such as the first ice skating rink, rock climbing wall, zip line, aqua theater, surf simulator, and 10-story slide (the Ultimate Abyss) at sea. Glow-in-the-dark laser tag, simulated skydiving, bumper cars, trapeze school and even robotic bartenders are a few of the other unique features you’ll find on Royal Caribbean. Royal Caribbean is also the only cruise line that offers Tony Award-winning shows at sea. You can expect to see Grease , Cats and other Broadway hits.

“Royal Caribbean’s entertainment is second-to-none, recently recognized as the best in the industry by Cruise Critic’s editors,” says Silverstein. (Another) case in point: Royal Caribbean recently launched a new private island experience, Perfect Day at CocoCay , with wild waterslides (including the tallest in North America), blissful beaches, a giant wave pool and a floating helium balloon ride.

Carnival:  Carnival offers traditional cruise ship activities featuring cruise directors that rile up guests in poolside contests and during evening entertainment. Your kids will be able to experience comedy shows and karaoke nights, which include the famous Lip Sync Battle . There’s also Hasbro , The Game Show, plus games and dive-in movies by the pool.

Continuously recognized by Cruise Hive’s Cruise Ship Awards as a fantastic domestic cruise line that delivers fun family experiences, Carnival also won Best Cruise Ship Feature for SkyRide , its suspended cycling experience. Carnival is also known for its Sky Zone trampoline park, available on select ships. For an added fee, kids can jump, climb a wall, dunk a basketball and play dodgeball for an hour. (Our children loved it so much, they went every day, giving us an hour to ourselves!). Silverstein also calls out the popular Carnival partnership with Dr. Suess that includes themed events, such as the Green Eggs and Ham breakfast, a costume parade, and Dr. Suess Bookville, a reading and play area.

Complimentary family fun includes the SportsSquare; with mini-golf, foosball and Ping-Pong; and WaterWorks, with adrenaline-inducing waterslides.

Related: 11 Things You Can’t Forget to Pack in Your Cruise Carry-On

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival: Family Dining

Royal Caribbean: Included dining involves the main dining room, Windjammer buffets and a few other options. For added fees, you can enjoy specialty restaurants such as steakhouses, sushi restaurants and celebrity-chef driven establishments, like Jamie Oliver’s Jamie’s Italian. My Family Time Dining is a great option for kiddos to eat with their parents for the first 40 minutes, and then get whisked off to the kids club so parents can enjoy the rest of their meal together.

Carnival:  Accolades for best cruise ship dining venue often go to Guy’s Burger Joint, which is free and available on all Carnival ships. The smashed burgers are total kid-pleasers. Carnival offers several other complimentary dining options, which include room service. Don’t miss the signature Carnival chocolate melting cake served in the main dining room!

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival: Family Cabins and Staterooms

Royal Caribbean: In 2019, Royal Caribbean launched another first at sea: the Ultimate Family Suite on Symphony of the Seas. The luxurious cabin has multiple TVs, video gaming systems, air hockey, a climbing maze, a floor-to-ceiling slide, and two bedrooms to sleep a total of eight guests. It also includes the service of a personal butler.

The price tag is out of most families’ budgets, but don’t worry; there are plenty of family-friendly room options available. “Royal Caribbean has a wealth of cabin selections- many with connecting doors- so families of all sizes and preferences can find a suitable option, at various price points,” says Silverstein. “That’s especially great for multi-generational groups, where you’re traveling with a wide range of family members.”

Royal Caribbean even offers interior rooms with virtual balconies, featuring 80-inch screens with real sights and sounds from outside. This is a great option for those on a budget.

Carnival:  Cabins that connect or sleep up to four or five guests make it easy to cruise with kids on Carnival Cruise Line. (Our family’s cabin, a standard category 8 balcony, included bunk beds for the kids and a king bed for the parents). Bathing and sleeping get even more comfortable when you reserve a family stateroom, featuring five berths (pull-down beds) and two bathrooms, and located in the Family Harbor section of Carnival ships. The Family Harbor Lounge (available on select ships), an area for families to relax with snacks, ice cream and video games .

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival: The Bottom Line

“Both Carnival and Royal Caribbean are fantastic options for families—with tons to do onboard, and plenty of family-focused features,” says Silverstein. The real difference is in the cost and number of inclusions, so decide which onboard experiences are most important to you and your kids before making your final decision.

Related: 7 Things You’ll Regret Not Packing for Your Family Cruise

Cortney Fries (pronounced “freeze”) is an award-winning Chicago-based writer and mom to two spunky elementary school-age kids. She loves nothing more than traveling with family, having adventures with friends and exploring the outdoors. Cortney believes that you should definitely do things that scare you just a little bit. Follow her on Instagram,  @cortneyfries.

What to Pack for Your Next Trip

Teen girl’s cool cruise outfit for summer, shop the look.

Colwyn Shirt

Bleach Joni Shorts

Canvas Tote Bag

Moment Espadrille

Dad’s/men’s cool cruise outfit for summer.

Striped Tee

Grey Chino Shorts

Mom’s/Women’s Cool Cruise Outfit for Summer

Lenny Tie Shirt

Mixed Broderie Midi Skirt

Flat Top Straw Hat

Shield Paddle Earrings

Teen Boy’s Cool Cruise Outfit for Summer

Pink Lemonade Shirt

Stone Utility Shorts

Polarized Sunglasses

Our team of parents and travel experts chooses each product and service we recommend. Anything you purchase through links on our site may earn us a commission.

Related Articles

What's the Minimum Age for a Cruise?

10 Best Alaska Cruises for Families 2020

6 Best Cruise Booking Sites for Families

10 Best Cruise Ship Family Cabins

Your personal family vacation planning starts now.

Get expert advice, handpicked recommendations, and tips for your family all year round!

Get family travel & tips from our experts

By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use .

Thanks for signing up!

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival: Which Is Best?

Considering a Caribbean cruise and wondering which is better, Royal or Carnival? We’re here to help with our comparison of Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival cruise line. We’ll tell you all about how these two popular choices stack up against each other so you can make an informed decision.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Quick Picks

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival cruise line overall: Depends on the type of experience you want to have and your budget

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival food: Both have top-quality food but Royal Caribbean has fewer included dining options

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival price: Carnival is less expensive

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival for families: Both offer plenty of activities and amenities for families, but Carnival wins due to its lower cost. However, if you have the budget, the family cabins on newer Royal Caribbean ships are incredible.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival for adults: Royal Caribbean offers a more sophisticated experience than Carnival, so it depends on the type of cruise you want to have.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Cruise Line Overview

There are both similarities and differences between Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Lines. Both have tons of activity and entertainment options, from contests to casinos to evening shows of all types.

On a Royal Caribbean cruise, however, you will tend to find some more unique activities and amazing offerings (like the world’s tallest waterslide, bumper cars, and ice skating). Carnival ships generally have more standard amenities, but that is changing somewhat with the newer Carnival ships. Fun new offerings include the first rollercoaster at sea.

In the U.S., both cruise lines depart from major U.S. cruise ports like Miami and Port Canaveral as well as smaller cities like Galveston, New Orleans, and Tampa. Royal Caribbean has ports on every coast, including areas in the Northeast, Mid-Atlantic, South, Pacific Northwest, and West. Carnival has fewer U.S. departure points than Royal Caribbean but also offers ports on all coasts. Both Carnival and Royal Caribbean have multiple itineraries in the western and eastern Caribbean .

Royal Caribbean visits more than 300 destinations and offers more cruises in other parts of the world in addition to the popular Caribbean and Mexico itineraries, such as Asia, Europe, North America, Alaska, South America, North Africa/Arabian Gulf, Australia, New Zealand, and the South Pacific. Royal Caribbean also offers transatlantic and transpacific crossings as well as an ultimate world cruise.

Carnival focuses more on the U.S., Caribbean, and Mexico, although they do have some cruises in Europe, Australia, New Zealand, the South Pacific, Asia, Bermuda, Hawaii, Alaska, Canada, and the Panama Canal. Carnival also offers some transatlantic and transpacific cruises.

Both Royal Caribbean and Carnival offer private islands, but currently Royal Caribbean’s is much more impressive (CocoCay has a huge pool, restaurants, and a giant waterslide). However, Carnival will be opening a new private island in the Bahamas in 2025 that should compete well.

While both Royal Caribbean and Carnival have both smaller and mega-ships, Royal Caribbean’s are larger. In fact, Royal Caribbean has five of the world’s biggest cruise ships including the newly launched Icon of the Seas, which took the place of the Wonder of the Seas as the largest cruise ship in the world.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Passengers

You’ll find a mix of ages on both cruise lines, but there are some differences. Most Carnival cruises are more affordable, have a laidback feel, and originate in the U.S., so you’ll find mostly American younger adults and families.

Royal Caribbean cruises draw more people from other countries in addition to Americans, and their higher price point translates to a more upscale atmosphere. However, the variety of exciting activities onboard means that plenty of younger adults and families enjoy these cruises as well.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival for Families

While Carnival has long been a favorite for families due to their focus on being the “fun ships” (and we consider them one of the best cruise lines for families ), Royal Caribbean keeps adding amazing amenities that make their ships extremely popular. The newest ships in particular have a lot that appeal to families.

For example, the new Icon of the Seas has the world’s largest waterpark at sea, 7 pools, and the “Stay All Day” Surfside neighborhood for families. Accommodations are also over the top, with special family suites like the 3-level Ultimate Family Townhouse with an indoor slide, a cinema room, and a private patio just off of the Surfside area.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival for Adults

Carnival ships are quite popular with families, especially those with younger children. Adults who would enjoy Carnival cruises tend to be those who like a party atmosphere, such as singles or friend groups. However, Carnival ships do offer adults-only areas, so it is possible to have a more romantic or “grown-up” experience onboard a Carnival cruise.

Although Royal Caribbean has plenty of family-friendly activities and amenities—especially the newer ships—it is a cruise line that appeals to a lot of adults. The higher price point also translates to a more upscale experience. You will typically find older passengers on a Royal Caribbean cruise, including many couples who are celebrating special events like honeymoons and anniversaries.

If you’re trying to decide on Carnival or Royal Caribbean for young adults, it may depend on what sort of cruise experience you want. If you’re interested in hanging out by the pool, enjoying tropical cocktails in the sun, and a casual good time, Carnival ships are better for you. If you want a more sophisticated feel, check out a Royal Caribbean cruise.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Activities

There are both similarities and differences in Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival activities on board the ship. As with any cruise line, the types of activities and facilities available vary depending on the specific ship you choose. But in general, both have tons of options, from movies to live game shows to contests to casinos to evening shows of all types, including comics, theater productions, live music, and more.

On a Royal Caribbean cruise, however, you will find some unique offerings like rock climbing walls, zip lines, ice skating, Flowrider surf simulators, and bumper cars. They also have things like the world’s tallest waterslide. You will also find shortened versions of Broadway shows, outdoor Aqua Theaters with high-divers and acrobats, salsa dance clubs, and multimedia shows.

In addition to a variety of entertainment options like live music and shows, Carnival ships generally have more standard amenities like swimming pools, waterslides, video arcades, mini-golf courses, and movie theaters. However, some of the newer Carnival ships feature unique amenities as well. These include Skybikes (suspended “pedal-powered go-mobiles” that you bike around a course, high in the air), IMAX theaters, outdoor ropes courses, the first rollercoaster at sea, and the first Sky Zone trampoline park at sea.

Carnival also offers Serenity Adult-Only Retreat areas and Cloud 9 Spas, as well as libraries, art exhibits and seminars, and sports like volleyball and basketball. Entertainment includes audience participation shows, trivia contests, comedy clubs, live shows with dancing and singing, and tons of live music.

Both cruise lines offer a wide variety of shore excursions to choose from, and both have good children’s programs with plenty of activities for all ages.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Cabins

While both cruise lines offer a wide variety of accommodations, Royal Caribbean offers a bigger selection than Carnival does. However, the standard cabins on Carnival ships are among the biggest of any cruise line.

Luxurious suites on Royal Caribbean ships include 2-story loft suites, 2-story Ultimate Family Suites with slides and game rooms, and suites that come with private concierges. The décor in Royal Caribbean cabins is more luxurious, and over-the-top than in Carnival cabins.

On Carnival, you will find a variety of cabin types but not as many as on Royal Caribbean. The look is laidback with bright colors. Carnival ships offer large Family Harbor suites as well as suites that come with access to private retreat spaces with lounge chairs and whirlpools.

The newer Carnival ships have more luxurious offerings. Staterooms are thoughtfully designed and feature all sorts of new amenities. For example, the Excel Presidential Suite on the Mardi Gras has a separate living room, dining area, and wet bar, plus a huge balcony with seating and an outdoor hot tub.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Food

The food on both Royal Caribbean and Carnival is said to be excellent, and you can get a variety of cuisines, from Asian to Mexican to Italian to Indian to steak and seafood to casual American fare, on both lines. Both cruise lines have partnerships with celebrity chefs for some of their restaurants, including Guy Fieri and Emeril Lagasse on Carnival and Jamie Oliver on Royal Caribbean.

Both offer a mix of places to eat that are included in your price, as well as a la carte restaurants that you have to pay extra for. However, there are fewer free choices on Royal Caribbean—it’s mostly a buffet and main dining rooms.

On Carnival ships, there are more free than paid restaurant choices, and you have a wide variety of outlets to choose from. Royal Caribbean tends to have more specialty restaurants than Carnival, and they are usually elegant and a bit expensive.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Drink Package

Neither Carnival or Royal Caribbean are all-inclusive cruise lines, so you will want to consider purchasing a drink package in advance. (Drink packages are a prepaid amount that buys you a certain number of beverages per day, so you’re not paying a premium price onboard, and know in advance how much you’ll be spending.)

There are drink packages for both nonalcoholic and alcoholic drinks on both Carnival and Royal Caribbean. Royal Caribbean has 4 drink packages : water, classic soda, refreshments, and deluxe. Carnival has 3 drink packages: bottomless bubbles for soda, a wine package, and an alcoholic beverage package.

While the specific cost can vary depending on the ship, itinerary, and travel dates, Carnival’s drink packages tend to be less expensive.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Price

A Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival cost comparison shows that while both cruise lines offer affordable options, Royal Caribbean tends to be a little more expensive than Carnival Cruise Lines.

Not only can you find inexpensive fares for Carnival cruises, but On-board expenses like drink prices and internet fees are a bit lower than those on Royal Caribbean.

Is Carnival the cheapest cruise line? In many cases, yes, cruises on Carnival are more affordable than on other cruise ships. However, this depends on the itinerary; other cruise lines can be cheaper on certain routes.

Now that you’ve read our comparison of Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival, are you ready to book a cruise? If so you may want to check out our Caribbean cruise packing list . And if you’d like help planning your cruise, feel free to reach out to one of our expert travel advisors !

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Cruise Line: Which Cruise Line is Best For You?

• March 24, 2023

Cruising the open seas is all about picking the right ship for your ideal vacation. When it comes to the biggest names in the cruising industry, Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line are on top of the list, but which one should you set sail with?

Both cruise lines offer sun-soaked destinations, onboard thrills, dining delights, and family fun, but they do so in different styles. 

While Royal Caribbean highlights being adventurous by providing rock climbing walls and surf simulators, Carnival keeps it laid back with themed water slides and comedy shows. 

Picking between the two cruise giants means weighing what really matters for your ideal cruise getaway, which is what we’re here to help you with in this Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Cruise Line guide. 

Types of ships

The Royal Caribbean fleet is known for its massive and imposing ships, with features like rock climbing walls, ice skating rinks, bumper cars, and even zip lines. They also have many dining options, from casual cafes to upscale restaurants.

Carnival, on the other hand, has a slightly more laid-back vibe. It has some unique features, including the famous BOLT roller coaster on its Excel class ships (Mardi Gras, Carnival Celebration, and Carnival Jubilee), a themed WaterWorks water park, and several themed bars and lounges.

If you’re looking for a more extravagant experience, Royal Caribbean may be the way to go, but if you prefer a more relaxed atmosphere, Carnival might be a better fit.

Destinations

Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line offer a variety of destinations, from the Bahamas and the Caribbean to Europe, Alaska, Australia, and beyond.

Royal Caribbean also offers itineraries to exotic destinations, like the South Pacific, Asia, and the Middle East.

Carnival tends to stick to more traditional cruise destinations.

Both cruise lines have their private island in The Bahamas. Royal Caribbean has Perfect Day at CocoCay, while Carnival shares Half Moon Cay with Holland America Line.

Popular ports for both lines in the U.S. include Port Canaveral, PortMiami, Galveston, New Orleans, and Los Angeles.

If you’re looking for a more unique and off-the-beaten-path itinerary, Royal Caribbean may be the better choice.

Cruise line vibe

Another factor to consider is the overall vibe of each cruise line. 

Royal Caribbean attracts a slightly more upscale and diverse crowd, mixing families, couples, and solo travelers. Per contra, Carnival is known for its party atmosphere and tends to attract a younger crowd.

Royal Caribbean may be the way to go if you’re looking for a more relaxed and sophisticated experience. But Carnival may be the better choice if you’re looking for a fun and lively atmosphere with plenty of nightlife options.

Onboard activities

Regarding onboard activities, Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line offer passengers a wide range of entertainment options. However, some notable differences between the two cruise lines are worth considering.

Royal Caribbean is known for its innovative and adrenaline-pumping activities, such as rock climbing walls, surf simulators, and zip lines. 

They also have many entertainment options, including Broadway-style shows, ice skating performances, and acrobatic shows.

Carnival Cruise Line caters more to families and offers a variety of fun activities for kids, such as water slides, mini-golf, basketball courts, and arcade games.

Carnival also partners with Dr. Seuss, meaning passengers can enjoy themed green eggs and ham character breakfasts, parties, and storytime sessions.

Both cruise lines also have spas with salon services and, depending on the vessel, may have a thermal suite add-on.

Royal Caribbean may be the better choice if you’re looking for an upscale feel and a wide range of innovative activities.

However, Carnival Cruise Line may be the way to go if you’re traveling with kids or looking for a more cost-effective option.

Regardless of which cruise line you choose, both offer a great selection of onboard activities to keep you busy.

Entertainment

Yes, Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line offer different entertainment options.

Royal Caribbean is known for its Broadway-style shows and innovative attractions like ice-skating rinks, rock-climbing walls, and surfing simulators. There are also themed parties, parades, and live music performances.

Carnival Cruise Line focuses more on comedy, karaoke, trivia, poolside contests, and game shows. They also have a popular water park called WaterWorks and a signature attraction called SkyRide (on Vista-class ships), where guests can ride bikes on a suspended track.

Both cruise lines offer plenty of options to keep passengers entertained, but the specific offerings vary depending on the ship and itinerary.

MORE: 12 Things to Know Before Sailing Royal Caribbean

Food and drink

Yes, the food options differ between Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line.

Both cruise lines offer a wide selection of dining options. While Royal Caribbean is known for its upscale feel and gourmet cuisine, Carnival Cruise Line offers a more casual dining experience.

Royal Caribbean’s main dining room features a varied menu with options like lobster bisque, filet mignon, and baked Alaska.

The cruise line also offers specialty restaurants like Jamie’s Italian, where passengers can enjoy Italian dishes created by celebrity chef Jamie Oliver. Upscale specialty venues like Wonderland and 150 Central Park are also available (both on select ships).

Additionally, Royal Caribbean offers a variety of casual dining options like Johnny Rockets and the Windjammer buffet.

Carnival Cruise Line’s main dining room offers a less formal atmosphere with steak, seafood, and pasta options.

The cruise line also offers specialty venues like Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse, Cucina Del Capitano Italian cuisine, and Bonsai Teppanyaki hibachi.

Carnival also has a variety of casual dining options like Guy’s Burger Joint , created by celebrity chef Guy Fieri, BlueIguana Cantina serving tacos and burritos, and the Lido Marketplace buffet.

While the food options differ between Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line, Carnival provides more options included in the price of your cruise.

When comparing Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line, one of the main factors that passengers consider is the quality of the cabins.

While both cruise lines offer a range of accommodation options, it’s important to keep in mind that there are some notable differences between the two.

Firstly, Royal Caribbean tends to offer more luxurious and upscale cabins on its newer ships, with a greater emphasis on premium amenities and features.

This is particularly evident in their suite offerings, such as private balconies, dedicated concierge services, and exclusive access to restaurants and lounges.

In comparison, Carnival Cruise Line tends to focus more on affordability and accessibility, with a broader range of cabins available at lower price points.

While this means the cabins may not be quite as nice, plenty of comfortable and well-appointed options exist, including balcony cabins and suites .

Both cruise lines offer a range of cabin categories, though, from interior and ocean-view rooms to more spacious suites with additional amenities.

Family cruising

Regarding family cruising, one of the key factors to consider is the kids and teen programs offered by cruise lines.

Carnival is known for its family-friendly atmosphere, which extends to its kids and teen programs.

The cruise line offers three different age groups for toddlers to teens: 2-5, 6-8, and 9-11.

Each age group has dedicated space and activities, such as arts and crafts, games, and movies.

For teens, Carnival offers two age groups: 12-14 and 15-17. The cruise line’s teen program is called Club O2 and provides a range of activities such as dance parties, video games, and sports tournaments.

The cruise line also offers a dedicated teens-only lounge called Circle C.

Royal Caribbean’s kids and teen program, called Adventure Ocean, is divided into six age groups from Royal babies up to teens: 6 months-36 months, 3-5 years old, 6-8 years old, 9-11 years old, 12-14 years old, and 15-17 years old.

Each age group has its own dedicated space and activities designed to cater to that age group’s specific needs and interests.

Royal Caribbean offers teens two age groups: 12-14 years old and 15-17 years old.

The cruise line’s teen program is called Teen Club, which provides various activities such as dance parties, karaoke, video games, and sports tournaments.

The cruise line also offers a dedicated teen-only lounge called The Living Room.

When comparing the kids and teen programs of Carnival and Royal Caribbean, both cruise lines offer a great variety of activities for children and teenagers.

However, Royal Caribbean’s Adventure Ocean program stands out for offering activities for children as young as six months old, which can be a great advantage for families with young children.

Additionally, Royal Caribbean’s program is divided into more age groups, allowing for more age-appropriate activities and a better overall experience for children and teenagers.

Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean offer great options for families looking for a fun cruising experience.

While Carnival has a more laid-back and casual atmosphere focusing on family-friendly activities, Royal Caribbean’s newer ships offer a more upscale feel with high-tech features and specialty dining options.

Regarding the cruise fare for Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line cruises, there are a few key differences to consider.

Overall, Royal Caribbean tends to be a bit more expensive than Carnival, but a few factors can impact your cruise’s cost.

One major factor that can impact the price of a Royal Caribbean cruise is the ship you choose.

Some newer, more upscale ships, like Oasis-class ships (Symphony of the Seas and Wonder of the Seas, among others), can be expensive, while older boats or those with fewer amenities may be more affordable.

Similarly, the time of year you cruise can also impact the cost. Royal Caribbean’s prices tend to be higher during peak travel seasons like summer and holidays, while prices may be more affordable during off-peak times.

Regarding Carnival, the prices tend to be more consistent across ships and seasons.

While there may be some variation based on factors like the length of the cruise or the cabin you choose, you’re generally more likely to find affordable fares on Carnival than on Royal Caribbean.

One thing to remember with both cruise lines is that while the initial fare may seem affordable, there are often additional costs to consider. Royal Caribbean and Carnival charge extra fees for specialty dining, drinks, and shore excursions, so include these costs into your budget when comparing prices.

Comparing Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line Packages

If you’re planning a cruise vacation and considering Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line, comparing their cruise packages is essential to make an informed decision.

Here are the best ways to compare Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Cruise Line:

• Passenger Experience: Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line cater to families, couples, and solo travelers, but Royal Caribbean is known for its upscale feel. On the other hand, Carnival Cruise Line offers a more casual and laid-back atmosphere.
• Dining: Royal Caribbean offers a more diverse selection of options, including specialty restaurants, while Carnival Cruise Line focuses more on the main dining room experience. If you’re a food enthusiast, Royal Caribbean may be the better choice (depending on the ship).
• Price: Both cruise lines offer a range of fares, but Royal Caribbean tends to be more expensive overall. However, Royal Caribbean may offer more value for your money with its luxurious amenities and activities.
• Onboard: Both cruise lines offer a variety of onboard activities, but Royal Caribbean is known for its adventurous options, such as zip lining and rock climbing. On the other hand, Carnival Cruise Line offers more traditional activities, such as mini-golf and poolside games.
• Overall Experience: The best way to compare Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line is to read reviews from past passengers and compare the specific features and amenities that matter most to you. Consider your budget, preferred level of service, and desired activities before deciding.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is royal caribbean better than carnival.

There’s no definitive answer to whether Royal Caribbean is “better” than Carnival, as both cruise lines offer different experiences that will appeal to different cruisers. 

Royal Caribbean ships tend to be larger and offer more high-tech amenities. Their overall vibe is more upscale. Carnival, on the other hand, provides a more laidback, party-oriented experience.

What’s more, Royal Caribbean are known to travel to more exotic destinations worldwide, while Carnival sticks to traditional cruise destinations. 

Which cruise line has the best food?

Royal Caribbean is considered the better option as far as food. They offer more formal, gourmet dishes like filet mignon, baked Alaska, and lobster. 

RC also has more specialty dining venues like Jamie’s Italian for celebrity chef fare, Wonderland for an artistic culinary experience, and 150 Central Park for upscale cuisine. 

Carnival’s dining experience is on the casual side, with basic steak and pasta dishes in the main dining room, with specialty restaurants like Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse coming at an added fee. 

What is the number-one cruise line?

The answer is Norwegian Cruise Line.

NCL has been the most notable innovator in the cruise industry for over 50 years. In fact, they were the first to eliminate set dining times and give cruisers the freedom to cruise on their own schedule to over 450 breathtaking destinations all around the world.

In Summary 

Overall, when it comes down to Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Cruise Line, it comes down to you and your family’s personal preferences and priorities.

For travelers prioritizing luxury amenities, unique destinations, and fine dining, Royal Caribbean is the better choice. For cruisers wanting a fun, festive vacation at a more affordable price point, you can’t go wrong with Carnival. 

READ NEXT: 8 Tips, Hacks, and Ways to Save Money on a Carnival Cruise

Carnival Spirit Ship Tour

• Norwegian Gem Set to Launch Cruises from Jacksonville in 2025
• Tender Issues Cause NCL Cruise Ships to Skip Venice
• The First Cruise Line in History Will Homeport in Washington, D.C.
• Carnival Expects Revenue Hit by Scraping Red Sea Transits on 12 Ships

Recent Posts

• Carnival Vista Returns to Service Following Propulsion Repairs
• Prince Tribute Show to Headline Norwegian Aqua Entertainment Lineup
• New Carnival Cruise Solar Project Helps Power Barcelona Homes
• Disney Cruise Line Tightens Birth Certificate Requirements for Kids Under 16

Bringing you 15 years of cruise industry experience. Cruise Radio prioritizes well-balanced cruise news coverage and accurate reporting, paired with ship reviews and tips.   

Quick links

Cruise Radio, LLC © Copyright 2009-2024 | Website Designed By   Insider Perks, Inc

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival: The Ultimate Showdown

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. We may receive compensation when you purchase via my links at no cost to you. See my disclosure for more information.

Royal Caribbean International and Carnival Cruise Line are the undisputed titans of the cruise industry. They are two of the biggest and most-traveled cruise lines worldwide and two of the best cruise lines for families .

Royal Caribbean dazzles with its “wow factor” – think enormous ships and unique activities like surf simulators and zip-lining. It’s all about grandeur and innovation. In contrast, Carnival offers a more casual vibe, perfect for a relaxing, fun-filled trip with its budget-friendly and family-oriented approach.

Table of Contents

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Cruise Line: At a Glance

Here’s a quick overview comparing Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Cruise Line at a glance:

Our Pick: Royal Caribbean.

Although both cruise lines have a similar number of ships, Royal Caribbean is the clear winner.

Royal Caribbean offers a cruise experience filled with innovative features and activities, ideal for those who seek adventure and cutting-edge technology. On the other hand, Carnival provides a more traditional, relaxed, and budget-friendly cruise experience, perfect for families and those new to cruising.

Royal Caribbean

Royal Caribbean is renowned for its impressive fleet, boasting some of the cruise industry’s largest and most innovative ships. Royal Caribbeans cruise ships , including the groundbreaking Oasis-class vessels, the world’s largest cruise ship, Icon of the Seas .

Royal Caribbean’s cruise ships push the boundaries of innovation with unique attractions like FlowRider surf simulators, skydiving simulators, and rock-climbing walls. Accommodations on Royal Caribbean ships are equally impressive, with innovative options like the Royal Loft Suite or cabins with virtual balconies displaying real-time ocean views on LED screens.

The cruise line attracts diverse passengers, particularly those drawn to a technologically advanced and activity-rich cruise experience. Royal Caribbean’s ships offer something for everyone to love.

Carnival Cruise Line

In contrast, Carnival Cruise Line’s fleet is characterized by cruise ships prioritizing a classic, family-friendly cruise experience. Carnival’s vessels are large but pale compared to Royal Caribbean’s largest cruise ships.

The ambiance on Carnival ships is decidedly fun and casual, with amenities that include water slides, mini-golf courses, and poolside movie screens. While they may not match the technological advancements of Royal Caribbean, Carnival ships offer an environment with traditional family fun.

Carnival’s fleet particularly appeals to families, first-time cruisers, and those seeking a budget-friendly, fun-packed vacation.

Royal Caribbean emerges as the clear winner for those seeking an extraordinary and diverse range of activities. While Carnival offers a fun experience with its traditional cruise activities, Royal Caribbean takes the concept of onboard entertainment to the next level.

Even though they are the top cruise line for at-sea thrills, they aren’t slowing down.

Each new ship brings brand-new experiences for passengers and continues to build upon the innovation of its predecessors. As part of Royal Caribbean’s Royal Amplified program , the cruise line updates nearly every ship in its fleet. So, no matter the ship’s age, you will find heart-racing onboard activities.

Royal Caribbean truly sets a high bar when it comes to onboard activities. They continue to be the innovation leader , emphasizing the “wow factor” with zip lining, bumper cars, 300-foot observation pods , and more.

Royal Caribbean cruise ships are a hub of exciting activities , offering many unique experiences that are hard to find elsewhere in the cruise industry. You can let your inner child run free surfing on the FlowRider surf simulator or experience the thrill of skydiving in a simulator.

For those who prefer traditional sports on a cruise ship , there are rock-climbing walls, basketball courts, pools, mini-golf, and ice-skating rinks.

Adults looking for a quiet getaway will feel relaxed at the Vitality Spa or the adults-only Solarium , which has a large pool deck with hot tubs and a full bar under a large glass canopy.

Carnival Cruise Line offers a more traditional set of activities focusing on basic family fun . Carnival’s ships have features like water slides and mini-golf courses, which are a hit among families and young travelers.

While the activities might not match the cutting-edge variety found on Royal Caribbean ships, they nonetheless provide a thoroughly enjoyable experience, especially for those looking for a traditional cruise holiday.

Recently, the cruise line has begun to innovate with the launch of BOLT, the world’s first roller coaster at sea. You’ll also find live game shows, mini-golf courses, and a sports deck complete with a ropes course.

Adults can find much-needed relaxation at the onboard spa or Serenity Adult-Only Retreat , a kids-free lounge area with a full bar.

Entertainment

Our Pick: Draw.

Both cruise lines offer different entertainment styles, each incredible in their own respects. While Royal Caribbean’s high-tech entertainment is truly mind-blowing, Carnival succeeds with its spin on traditional cruise ship entertainment that keeps the party going all night. Each cruise line provides a different experience that comes down to personal preference.

Royal’s entertainment options stand out because of their spectacular and high-tech flourishes. Passengers enjoy Broadway-style shows comparable to what you’d see in New York’s theater district, bringing a touch of grandeur and artistic excellence to the sea.

Additionally, Royal Caribbean ships often feature high-tech shows, including spectacular ice-skating performances and aquatic theater shows in the unique AquaTheater . The entertainment extends beyond these large productions, with live music, comedy shows, and interactive experiences that keep guests entertained throughout their journey.

The Two70 entertainment venue, for example, is a cutting-edge multimedia concert experience with video projection and moving screens controlled by robotic arms.

Carnival Cruise Line, often called the ‘fun ships,’ offers entertainment that aligns with its lively and upbeat brand image. Carnival’s entertainment roster includes stand-up comedy shows and energetic musical performances that range from rock bands to solo artists.

While less flashy or tech-focused, their entertainment is a big reason passengers return time and time again. The Punchliner Comedy Club features R-rated and family-friendly shows from talented and well-known performers. Classic disco parties and piano bars are also popular nighttime venues.

While Carnival’s past stage shows may have been lackluster, they have made significant strides in bringing quality shoes to the stage at sea. Their Playlist Productions features LED screens and special effects , bringing high-energy stage shows to life. Their shows include “America Rocks,” “Amor Cubano,” “Flick,” “Epic Rock,” and “Heart and Soul.”

Carnival’s ships also host themed nights and deck parties that encourage guest participation, creating an environment that’s both interactive and entertaining. Their high-energy entertainment always keeps passengers dancing and singing night after night.

While the entertainment on Carnival might not have the same production value as Royal Caribbean, there’s never a dull moment on board.

Dining, Bars & Lounges

Our Pick: Tie.

Both cruise lines offer various dining and drinking experiences, each excelling uniquely. Royal Caribbean stands out for its diverse culinary options and sophisticated bar settings, while Carnival shines with its fun, relaxed dining atmosphere and American favorites.

The choice between the two ultimately comes down to personal preference: Royal Caribbean is best if you prioritize culinary diversity and sophistication, but Carnival is better for fun, casual dining, and drinking experience.

Royal Caribbean offers a diverse dining experience catering to various tastes and preferences. Their ships feature a variety of dining options, from casual buffets to formal dining rooms, and include a selection of specialty restaurants.

Royal’s specialty restaurants provide cuisines ranging from Italian to Asian fusion, providing an upscal dining experience at a cost.

The wide selection of specialty restaurants may disappoint cruisers who prefer the all-inclusive approach to cruising. I often feel pressured by crew members to purchase Royal Caribbean’s specialty dining packages .

Royal Caribbean’s bars and lounges are as diverse as their dining options.

From sophisticated wine bars and cozy pubs to lively dance clubs and unique venues like the Bionic Bar with robotic bartenders, there is something to suit every mood. The drinks’ quality and the bartenders’ expertise contribute to an exceptional bar experience, making it a perfect choice for those who enjoy exploring different types of beverages in various settings.

Carnival Cruise Line excels in offering a traditional American dining experience that is both enjoyable and relaxed. Carnival provides everything from casual eateries to upscale dining.

Their main dining rooms offer traditional and contemporary dishes , while the buffet options are extensive and varied. Carnival also features specialty restaurants, including popular choices like Guy Fieri’s burger joint , Shaquille O’Neil’s Big Chicken , and seafood options. Unlike Royal Caribbean, Carnival offers several alternative eateries for free.

Carnival Cruise Line’s approach to bars and lounges focuses on creating a lively and engaging atmosphere. Their ships feature a range of options, including themed bars, poolside bars, and nightclubs. The vibe is consistently upbeat, with a focus on fun and entertainment .

Carnival is well known for its signature cocktails and festive drink menus , making its bars a go-to spot for those looking to enjoy a lively night out.

Our Pick: Carnival.

In the battle of nightlife between Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line, Carnival emerges as the clear winner for those seeking a fun and energetic nightlife. While Royal Caribbean offers a sophisticated and polished experience, Carnival takes the crown for its unbeatable, high-energy environment.

Carnival’s ability to create a consistently lively and entertaining nightlife scene makes it the top choice for passengers who prioritize a vibrant and festive evening experience during their cruise.

Carnival is the clear winner after sailing on both cruise lines, with an unbeatable nighttime party at sea.

Royal Caribbean offers a diverse and vibrant nightlife scene on its ships. Passengers enjoy various options, including sophisticated wine bars, lively dance clubs, and unique lounges.

The entertainment is varied, from live music performances to DJ-led dance parties , ensuring that there’s something for every taste.

Royal Caribbean’s larger ships boast impressive venues like the AquaTheater, Two70 Theatre, and ice rinks, where nighttime shows are a visual spectacle. The nightlife is extensive and diverse, with a more upscale and polished feel , catering to a wide range of preferences.

While Royal Caribbean’s nightlife is fine for most cruise-goers, it’s not quite the party atmosphere some travelers desire.

Carnival Cruise Line, often called the ‘fun ships,’ truly shines regarding nightlife. The emphasis is on creating a high-energy, engaging party atmosphere that encourages guests to let loose and have fun.

Carnival’s ships feature a variety of lively venues , including popular themed bars, karaoke lounges, and nightclubs that keep the party going well into the night. The energy is infectious , with activities like deck parties, live music, and dance competitions involving everyone.

Carnival’s approach to nightlife is all about fun and inclusivity , making it a hit among passengers looking for a lively, less formal evening experience.

Kids & Families

Royal wins due to its drop-off daycare for babies and tots, a service not offered by many cruise lines. In addition, their ships have activities and adventures for kids of all ages, so you won’t need to worry about your family members getting bored at sea.

Royal Caribbean stands out with its comprehensive family and kids programs, tailored to entertain and engage children of all ages. Royal Caribbean’s Adventure Ocean program is among the cruise industry’s best kids’ and teen clubs.

Adventure Ocean offers age-appropriate activities and educational programs . The activities are not just fun but also creatively designed to be enriching, including science experiments, art projects, themed parties, and a DJ academy.

One of the unique features of Royal Caribbean is its paid nursery service , which caters to the youngest cruisers, infants, and toddlers. The Royal Babies & Tots service is a game-changer for parents, providing professional care for babies as young as six months , allowing parents to enjoy some personal time with the assurance that their little ones are in good hands.

Carnival Cruise Line offers a robust family and kids program , primarily through its Camp Ocean . Carnival’s kids club provides a fun and safe environment for children to play and learn. Carnival’s ships also feature family-friendly amenities like water slides and pools, which are big hits among younger passengers.

At Camp Ocean, kids are divided into three groups : Penguins (ages 2 to 5 years), Stingrays (ages 6 to 8 years), and Sharks (ages 9 to 11 years). Kids enjoy fun-filled activities with their group, including arts and crafts, singing, dancing, toys, games, movies, and video games.

When the sun goes, the club offers Night Owls , where kids get to stay up late having fun while their parents enjoy themselves well into the night – fees apply.

Cabins and Accommodations

Royal Caribbean was the clear winner in the past, with its modern, upscale decor, family cabins, and range of cabin choices. But Carnival has closed the gap with its newer ships, offering more stateroom options and larger staterooms.

Royal Caribbean impresses with its innovative design elements and luxurious suite options, catering to those looking for a high-tech or more upscale accommodation experience. On the other hand, Carnival excels in providing cozy, comfortable, and value-focused cabins, perfect for families and those who prioritize comfort and simplicity in their cruise accommodations.

Royal Caribbean’s cabins are designed to cater to a wide range of preferences and budgets, offering everything from standard interior rooms to luxurious suites.

One of the standout features of their cabins is the innovative design elements , such as virtual balconies in interior rooms , which display real-time ocean views on high-definition screens. This feature is particularly appealing for those who want a view without the price tag of a balcony room.

The suites on Royal Caribbean ships are a highlight, offering spacious layouts, luxurious amenities, and additional perks like access to exclusive lounges and dining areas. Families can also find larger cabins that accommodate larger groups comfortably. The standout cabins are the Oasis-class Ultimate Family Suite and the Icon-class Ultimate Family Townhouse .

The interior decor is a little more upscale and elegant compared to Carnival. The sleek color palette resembles what you might find in a modern, upscale hotel.

Carnival Cruise Line is known for its comfortable and efficiently designed cabins . The cruise line’s focus on maximizing space and comfort makes it ideal for families and those looking for a cozy, inviting space to relax after a day of activities. Carnival’s cabins are generally bright and cheerfully decorated , aligning with the line’s fun and upbeat brand image.

Carnival also offers a range of cabin categories, from basic interior rooms to more upscale suites. While they might not have the high-tech features of Royal Caribbean’s cabins, they are well-regarded for their cleanliness, comfort, and value. The suites on Carnival ships provide extra space and amenities, making them an excellent option for those looking for a bit more luxury.

Itineraries

Royal Caribbean takes the win, offering more destinations, itineraries, and sailing durations with something for everyone to love. Carnival Cruise Line is starting to expand beyond the sunny Caribbean with more Alaskan, Australian, and European sailings—an excellent move in our books.

Royal Caribbean offers a broad and diverse range of itineraries across the globe . Their itineraries include popular destinations, including the Caribbean, Bahamas, Alaska, Europe, Asia, and even transatlantic voyages.

One of the standout aspects of Royal Caribbean’s itineraries is the inclusion of exotic and less-traveled destinations , offering unique experiences to travelers seeking new adventures.

Additionally, Royal Caribbean often features longer cruises , which allows for more in-depth exploration of the regions they visit. Their itineraries are well-planned, including a mix of popular tourist destinations and hidden gems, ensuring a comprehensive travel experience.

While offering a wide range of destinations, Carnival Cruise Line focuses more on popular and traditional cruise destinations , particularly in the Caribbean and Bahamas. Carnival is known for its fun and sun-oriented itineraries , making it a favorite for those looking for a classic beach vacation experience.

They offer a variety of short and long cruises, with many options for 3- to 7-day trips , which are ideal for first-time cruisers or those looking for a quick getaway. While Carnival does sail to other destinations like Alaska and Europe, its strength lies in its extensive Caribbean offerings.

Private Islands

Royal’s CocoCay is in a league of its own. Even before the extensive renovation, the island was home to more thrills and activities than any other private island in the business.

In line with its ships, the island provides diverse activities, from high-thrill balloon rides to relaxing private cabanas over the crystal blue ocean. The island is so popular that many vacationers only sail on itineraries that visit the popular private island.

Royal Caribbean offers an exceptional experience with its private islands, most notably Perfect Day at CocoCay in the Bahamas . The island has been transformed into an ultimate vacation getaway with features like Thrill Waterpark, home to the tallest waterslide in North America, a 1,600-foot zipline, and a helium balloon ride offering panoramic views.

Additionally, CocoCay provides a range of relaxing beachfront areas , infinity pools, and private cabanas, including overwater cabanas in the exclusive Coco Beach Club. This blend of adventure and luxury on a private island setting sets Royal Caribbean apart in terms of offering a unique and versatile island experience.

After a mega $250 million upgrade, CocoCay has more than enough amenities for up to 6,000 cruisers daily. The opening of South Beach and the VIP Coco Beach Club provides plenty of space for sports-loving travelers or laid-back relaxation.

Carnival Cruise Line’s private island experiences, such as Half Moon Cay in the Bahamas, are focused more on the natural beauty and serene beach experience . Half Moon Cay is known for its stunning white-sand beaches, crystal-clear waters, and various water sports activities.

While it doesn’t boast the same level of high-adrenaline attractions as Royal Caribbean’s CocoCay, Half Moon Cay offers a more laid-back, traditional beach day experience . The island provides amenities like beachside cabanas, various dining options, and nature trails, making it a perfect destination for those looking to relax and enjoy the natural beauty of the Bahamas.

Carnival Cruise Line has built its reputation on affordable cruises for the entire family. And they deliver. Carnival cruise fares are among the lowest in the industry. The base cruise fare on a Carnival cruise includes many onboard dining and entertainment options.

While sailing with Royal Caribbean International can undoubtedly be worth the additional cost, we don’t like the added expenses for dining and activities that we feel should be standard. We often find ourselves pushed to spend more on Royal Caribbean ships than Carnival.

In general, it isn’t easy to compare costs as prices vary depending on the destination, ship, itinerary, and time of year. Both cruise lines are pretty equal in pricing, but Carnival tends to be a bit more affordable.

Royal Caribbean is best known for its innovative fleet , offering various amenities and activities for cruisers of all ages. Royal Caribbean’s cruise fare typically includes your cabin, standard meals in the main dining room and buffet, some beverages (like water, tea, and lemonade), and access to most onboard activities and entertainment. Specialty dining, Voom WiFi , soda, and alcoholic beverages cost extra.

You can find plenty of budget-friendly sailings on Royal Caribbean’s older cruise ships but expect to pay a lot more if you want to sail on their newest vessels.

Prices on Royal Caribbean’s newest ships are significantly higher, especially during peak traveling season. Although much of the dining and amenities are included, plenty of activities and specialty restaurants cost extra.

One major inconvenience is that I feel the cruise line is very pushy with their add-ons . Think dining packages, WiFi, spa treatments, and the Deluxe Beverage Package . From the moment you step on board, you’re bombarded by crew members asking you to upgrade your cruise package.

It’s not enough to ruin a cruise vacation, but it’s definitely an inconvenience.

Often hailed as the more budget-friendly option , Carnival offers some of the lowest fares in the cruise industry. Carnival’s cruise fare includes accommodation, basic dining options, and most entertainment and onboard activities.

Carnival is renowned for its value for money , providing a fun and relaxed atmosphere without a hefty price tag. However, like Royal Caribbean, specialty dining, certain onboard activities, and premium entertainment might incur extra costs.

But unlike Royal Caribbean, I don’t feel nickel and dimed when I sail. Carnival’s cruise ships offer several complimentary alternative restaurants, and I don’t find the staff as pushy trying to get us to upgrade.

In comparing Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line, Royal Caribbean is the superior choice for travelers seeking a diverse and innovative cruise experience. With its technologically advanced and activity-rich fleet, Royal Caribbean caters to adventure enthusiasts and those seeking cultural experiences. Their ships boast unique attractions, diverse dining options, and cabins with innovative features like virtual balconies.

Royal Caribbean’s itineraries stand out with their inclusion of exotic destinations, and the private island experience at Perfect Day at CocoCay offers an unmatched blend of excitement and relaxation.

While Carnival provides a fun and budget-friendly option , Royal Caribbean’s dedication to innovation, variety, and quality makes it the top choice for a memorable and all-encompassing cruise vacation.

Royal Caribbean is the clear winner for those seeking an unparalleled cruise experience that combines adventure, luxury, and unique experiences.

Marcello De Lio

Trending now

Stay in the Loop: The latest cruise DEALS & NEWS delivered to your inbox - Click Here!

CruiseOverload

Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival: Which Cruise Giant Wins the Battle of the Seas?

When you think about going on a cruise, two big names probably come to mind: Royal Caribbean and Carnival. They’re well known worldwide and dominate the open seas.

These two cruise lines are like the best of rivals, offering amazing trips to numerous places, fun activities for all ages, and all sorts of adventures.

But even though they seem similar, there are some differences that might help you pick the one that’s just right for you.

Let’s dive into the fun battle between Royal Caribbean and Carnival to see which one you might want to hop aboard for your next vacation!

Table of Contents

Royal Caribbean vs Carnival

Tackling fleet sizes, Royal Caribbean boasts an impressive array of ships. It’s not just about numbers; it’s the variety and the cutting-edge technology that they incorporate.

From the world’s largest cruise ships in the Oasis class to the adventurous Quantum class, Royal Caribbean ships are floating cities brimming with activities and amenities.

The sheer scale of Royal Caribbean’s Oasis and Icon Classes is so vast that they’re cleverly segmented into neighborhoods. Imagine strolling through an authentic Central Park complete with actual trees or reveling in the pleasures of a lively Boardwalk.

Here, merriment is always in the air with carousels and thrilling slides, not to mention a state-of-the-art theater where you can be mesmerized by daring high-dives.

Carnival has a more family-focused approach. Their ships are known for a fun atmosphere and are designed to cater to all ages.

Carnival’s approach to grandiosity is no less spectacular, with their largest liners, including the Mardi Gras , Carnival Celebration, and Carnival Jubilee, each boasting a collection of themed zones.

Aboard Mardi Gras, for example, you can sway to the rhythms of jazz in an environment inspired by New Orleans’ own French Quarter.

With a fleet that’s recently expanded with its innovative Excel-class ships, Carnival is dedicated to affordable, lively vacations that appeal to both the young and the young at heart.

On the more modest side, both lines provide vessels that comfortably host between 3,000 and 4,000 passengers.

No ship, regardless of its size, neglects to deliver the full cruise experience. Brace yourself for an array of luxurious amenities ranging from bustling casinos, serene pools, and live entertainment to indulgent spas, vibrant dance halls, and an assortment of bars.

Both Carnival and Royal Caribbean guarantee that your ocean voyage will feel like a retreat to an indulgent resort—a world where both relaxation and entertainment await at every deck.

Accommodations

Rest easy knowing you have an abundance of room options to choose from. Royal Caribbean’s accommodations range from cozy interior rooms to expansive suites with private balconies.

If cruising solo, you have the option of single cabins that mean you won’t be paying double just to have your own space.

Now, if it’s spaciousness you’re after, Carnival’s standard cabins are notable for their generous size, leading the industry in room to relax and enjoy your cruise. Comfort meets style in rooms designed with warm accents and all the necessary amenities.

While slightly less geared towards solo travelers, Carnival still provides a variety of room types, including budget-friendly interior cabins and suite options for extra luxury.

For those cruising with family, certain ships offer Family Harbor cabins, complete with access to a communal lounge perfect for family time.

Meanwhile, sailing on one of Carnival’s latest ships treats you to an elevated experience with increased availability of suites, including some that provide daytime access to an exclusive pool area.

If you’re planning to book a standard room, you’ll find that both Royal Caribbean and Carnival offer similar quality and comfort. However, it’s a good idea to explore the special room options each cruise line offers.

These unique rooms might give you the chance to enjoy a balcony view at a lower cost, or you could opt for a themed suite that adds an extra touch of magic to your journey.

Each cruise line has its own set of exclusive accommodations that could make your trip even more memorable, without necessarily breaking the bank.

Destinations and Itineraries

When choosing between Royal Caribbean and Carnival, the destinations they visit and the creativity of their itineraries might just tip the scales.

Each line charts its own course across the seas, offering distinct journeys that beckon travelers with the promise of adventure and discovery.

Royal Caribbean is renowned for its diverse array of destinations, particularly its voyages across the Caribbean Sea.

These cruises range from short 3-7 night jaunts to longer excursions, docking at popular spots like the Bahamas and Cozumel.

What sets Royal Caribbean apart are its private destinations, such as Labadee in Haiti—a secluded resort offering everything from pristine beaches to exhilarating zip-line adventures.

Another exclusive stop is Perfect Day at CocoCay in the Bahamas, where guests can enjoy an action-packed waterpark and relaxing beach areas.

For those drawn to the old world charm and natural beauty of Europe, Royal Caribbean offers itineraries that explore the Mediterranean’s rich history and the Baltic Sea’s breathtaking vistas, with trips typically lasting 7 nights or more.

Carnival Cruise Line , on the other hand, provides a treasure trove of tropical paradises within the Caribbean, with itineraries ranging from quick 4-night getaways to more leisurely 8-night sails.

For those looking westward, Carnival’s cruises to the Mexican Riviera promise sun-soaked adventures in ports like Cabo San Lucas and Puerto Vallarta, perfect for 6-night escapes.

While Carnival may not offer private islands like its competitor, it prides itself on delivering unique shore excursions that immerse travelers in the local culture and scenic beauty of each port, ensuring a memorable experience at every stop.

In essence, your preference for destinations and the way you wish to explore them could very well make the decision for you.

Private Island Experiences

Royal caribbean’s private island: perfect day at cococay.

Perfect Day at CocoCay is Royal Caribbean’s private island in the Bahamas, known for its thrilling and chill experiences. It’s an adventurous paradise featuring:

• Thrill Waterpark : Home to Daredevil’s Peak, the tallest waterslide in North America, along with several other slides, wave pools, and a kid-friendly obstacle course.
• Up, Up and Away : A helium balloon ride that offers breathtaking views of the island from 450 feet in the air.
• Oasis Lagoon : The Caribbean’s largest freshwater pool, complete with swim-up bars and in-pool loungers.
• Chill Island : A serene beach escape with crystal-clear waters and powdery white sands, perfect for relaxation.
• Coco Beach Club : Offering an upscale experience with overwater cabanas, a private beach, and an exclusive restaurant.

Royal Caribbean has designed Perfect Day at CocoCay to offer a balanced mix of adrenaline-pumping adventures and serene relaxation spots, catering to all ages and preferences.

Carnival’s Private Island: Half Moon Cay

Half Moon Cay is Carnival’s private island in the Bahamas, consistently rated as one of the best private islands in the Caribbean. It epitomizes the idyllic beach day with features like:

• Stunning, award-winning beaches : With powdery white sand and crystal-clear turquoise waters, the beaches are perfect for swimming, sunbathing, and beach sports.
• Horseback riding by the sea : Unique to Half Moon Cay, guests can ride horses along the beach and even through the surf.
• Water sports : Including snorkeling, kayaking, and paddleboarding, allowing guests to explore the island’s vibrant marine life.
• Private cabanas : Available for rent, offering a private slice of paradise with added comforts and amenities.
• Nature trails : For guests interested in exploring the island’s natural beauty on foot or by bike.

Half Moon Cay focuses on delivering a pristine beach experience in a more laid-back and natural setting, making it ideal for guests looking to unwind and soak in the beauty of the Bahamas.

Each cruise line brings its own strengths to the table, making your dining experience a key part of the adventure.

Carnival Cruise Line shines with its expansive selection of included dining options, creating a gastronomic landscape that’s as inclusive as it is diverse. The line’s commitment to quality and variety is evident in both its complimentary and specialty dining offerings.

For meat enthusiasts, the steakhouses on Carnival ships are a must-visit, offering premium cuts in an elegant setting. Asian cuisine lovers will find themselves at home in JiJi, where the flavors of the East are celebrated with flair.

But the culinary delights don’t stop there. Carnival’s collaboration with celebrity chefs brings an extra layer of excitement to your dining options.

Guy Fieri’s poolside burgers at Guy’s Burger Joint, the varied tastes at BlueIguana Cantina, Shaq’s crispy fried chicken, and the Italian pizzas offer a taste of the familiar with a twist. For those with a love for Indian cuisine, the main dining room’s nightly vegetarian options are a testament to Carnival’s attention to diverse palates.

Adding to the experience, selected ships feature New Orleans bistros by Emeril Lagasse and in-house breweries, offering a unique blend of culinary exploration and craft beverages, though these experiences come at an additional cost.

Royal Caribbean , on the other hand, invites guests to embark on a culinary journey that spans the globe without leaving the ship.

The Windjammer Marketplace buffet and traditional main dining rooms are at the heart of the complimentary dining experience, offering a range of familiar and comforting dishes designed to please every palate.

For those seeking a more specialized dining experience, Royal Caribbean’s array of specialty restaurants provides an opportunity to indulge in everything from sushi to Italian cuisine, albeit for an additional fee.

Noteworthy is Jamie’s Italian by Jamie Oliver, offering rustic Italian favorites in a casual setting. For a taste of Americana, Johnny Rockets serves up classic burgers and milkshakes, though it’s important to note there is a charge for this nostalgic experience.

Both Royal Caribbean and Carnival excel in providing a dining experience that is both broad and nuanced, catering to the tastes of every traveler.

Whether you’re drawn to the comprehensive, inclusive offerings of Carnival with its celebrity chef partnerships and diverse cuisine options or the global culinary exploration facilitated by Royal Caribbean’s specialty venues and buffet, your cruise will undoubtedly be a journey worth savoring.

Onboard Activities

Both cruise lines pull out all the stops to ensure that your days at sea are filled with excitement, laughter, and awe-inspiring performances.

Royal Caribbean sets the bar high with its array of Broadway-style shows, where the glamour and talent could easily be mistaken for a night out in New York City.

But the entertainment doesn’t stop there. Guests can marvel at ice-skating performances that turn the rink into a stage of glacial beauty, and acrobatic shows that defy gravity and capture the imagination.

For those seeking a dose of adrenaline, Royal Caribbean offers unique experiences such as surf simulators and skydiving simulators, allowing you to catch a wave or soar through the air without ever leaving the ship.

The adventure continues with rock climbing walls, the FlowRider surfing simulator, ice skating, and even zip lines, ensuring that every moment is filled with excitement. Not to be overlooked, the Ultimate Abyss slide and the North Star observation pod offer breathtaking thrills and views, respectively.

Carnival Cruise Line , on the other hand, ensures that fun is at the heart of your vacation. The Punchliner Comedy Club promises a night of belly laughs, while live music and dance shows keep you moving to the beat.

But Carnival’s sense of adventure shines through with its WaterWorks parks, featuring twisting waterslides and splash zones for a splash-tacular time.

For those seeking a unique thrill, the Bolt sea-bound roller coaster offers high-speed excitement with ocean views.

Additional adventures include outdoor ropes courses, sky-high bike rides, and even indoor trampoline parks, ensuring that every day is filled with new and exciting challenges.

Both cruise lines also cater to those looking for relaxation or a flutter of excitement with amenities like casinos, spas, and pools, ensuring that whether you’re seeking adrenaline, entertainment, or a moment of peace, there’s something onboard for you.

Whether you’re drawn to Royal Caribbean’s innovative and high-flying activities or Carnival’s fun-filled and diverse entertainment options, your cruise vacation promises to be an unforgettable journey of discovery and delight.

Entertainment

Both cruise lines have mastered the art of sea-bound entertainment, offering a variety of shows and activities that cater to every taste and age group.

Royal Caribbean transforms your evenings into an unforgettable Broadway experience. Picture yourself tapping your feet and singing along to the timeless hits from shows like “Grease,” “Hairspray,” and “Cats.”

These aren’t mere performances; they’re Broadway productions at sea, meticulously adapted to enrich your night without keeping you out too late.

For those who crave the thrill of the extraordinary, Royal Caribbean’s AquaTheaters are the stage for heart-stopping acrobatic and high-diving performances, all set against the vast backdrop of the ocean. Meanwhile, ice skating shows bring a cool twist to onboard entertainment, combining grace and skill on a glistening rink.

And for a fusion of technology and performance art, the Two70 theaters on Quantum Class ships offer a spectacle where robotics and live actors create an immersive storytelling experience.

Royal Caribbean also knows how to get your feet moving with places like Boleros, a vibrant salsa club where the rhythm of the music invites you to dance the night away under the stars.

Carnival Cruise Line offers its own brand of unforgettable nights with Playlist Productions. These high-energy performances distill the essence of musical theatre into shorter, dynamic shows that blend popular tunes with dazzling choreography.

Comedy takes center stage at the Punchliner Comedy Clubs, showcasing Carnival’s commitment to laughter with a lineup that makes it the largest employer of comedians worldwide.

The musical journey continues throughout the ship, with live bands playing everything from soothing jazz to electrifying rock ‘n’ roll, ensuring there’s a beat for every moment of your journey.

Interactive entertainment is a Carnival hallmark, from the spirited competition of “Family Feud” to lively poolside games and music trivia that bring guests together in laughter and play. Each day and night, Carnival transforms the cruise into a celebration of fun, music, and community.

On both Royal Caribbean and Carnival cruises, the promise isn’t just a journey across the ocean but an immersion into a world where entertainment is crafted to surprise, delight, and engage.

Whether it’s the allure of Broadway at sea, the pulse of live music, or the laughter shared in a comedy club, your time onboard is an adventure in entertainment.

Kids Activities

Royal Caribbean takes child-friendly adventures to the next level with its Adventure Ocean program. This initiative is a haven for kids aged 3 to 12, inviting them to embark on a journey of exploration and discovery.

Through engaging activities and challenges, children have the opportunity to become mini-scientists, artists, and explorers, all while earning special badges that celebrate their achievements.

But the fun isn’t limited to just the older kids; Royal Caribbean has thoughtfully designed spaces for babies and toddlers, providing a safe and stimulating environment for the youngest guests to play and learn under the careful guidance of trained professionals.

This inclusive approach ensures that families with children of all ages can enjoy a stress-free vacation, knowing their little ones are engaged in enriching and entertaining experiences.

Carnival Cruise Line , on the other hand, invites kids to dive deep into ocean-themed fun at Camp Ocean. This program caters to children from 2 to 11 years old, offering a wide range of activities that celebrate the wonder of the sea.

Adding a sprinkle of magic to the mix, Carnival’s partnership with Dr. Seuss transforms the cruise into a floating storybook. Interactive character experiences, story times, and themed breakfasts featuring beloved characters from Dr. Seuss’s world ensure that imagination and fun are always on the menu.

For tweens and teens, Carnival provides exclusive spaces that are perfectly tailored to their interests and social styles.

These areas boast video games, cozy seating, and versatile spaces that adapt to everything from laid-back hangouts to high-energy dance parties, giving older kids the freedom to enjoy their vacation in their own way.

Both Royal Caribbean and Carnival understand that a family vacation is about creating lasting memories for every family member, no matter their age.

With their dedicated children’s programs, safe and engaging spaces, and a wide array of activities, parents can relax and indulge in the adult-focused amenities of the cruise, secure in the knowledge that their kids are having the time of their lives.

This commitment to family-friendly fun ensures that a cruise vacation is a richly rewarding experience for adventurers of all ages.

Pricing and Value

Royal Caribbean positions itself slightly higher on the pricing spectrum, a reflection of its commitment to innovation and the comprehensive range of facilities aboard its fleet.

The price of a journey with Royal Caribbean can fluctuate significantly, influenced by factors such as the chosen destination, the length of the cruise, and the specific ship.

This variance underscores the brand’s appeal to those seeking a cruise experience that’s enriched with state-of-the-art amenities and exclusive onboard activities.

Carnival , in contrast, sails a course that’s more budget-friendly, offering an appealing array of options for those looking to maximize fun without stretching their wallet too thin.

Carnival’s approach is especially attractive to families and budget-savvy travelers, offering a compelling mix of entertainment and relaxation at a value that’s hard to beat.

Included Amenities

The ticket price is just the beginning; the true value of a cruise comes alive through the myriad of experiences and amenities included.

Royal Caribbean dazzles with its adventurous offerings:

• Surf simulators and rock-climbing walls for the thrill-seekers.
• Ice-skating rinks and multiple pool areas that cater to all ages and preferences.

Carnival counters with its own brand of onboard excitement:

• Exhilarating water slides and poolside movie nights under the stars.
• Comedy clubs and themed parties that ensure every night is an event.

Both lines generously incorporate basic dining options and a diverse array of entertainment into the base fare, allowing guests to enjoy much of what the ship has to offer without additional costs.

Additional Costs

The voyage beyond the ticket price can encounter seas of additional expenses, from gratuities and specialty dining to excursions and beverage packages.

• Gratuities are an expected expense on both lines, contributing to the staff’s livelihood who make your stay memorable.
• Specialty dining venues offer culinary explorations beyond the included meals, featuring gourmet dishes and celebrity chef creations at an extra charge.
• Excursions and special activities , whether onshore adventures or onboard exclusives like spa treatments, enrich your cruise experience with additional costs.
• Beverage packages can be a wise investment for those looking to enjoy unlimited soft drinks or alcoholic beverages, offering convenience and potential savings.

Deciding between Royal Caribbean and Carnival doesn’t have to feel like navigating through a storm.

By considering both the upfront costs and the value of the experiences each line offers, travelers can chart a course to a cruise that not only fits their budget but also fulfills their dreams of an unforgettable sea adventure.

Whether you’re drawn to the innovative allure of Royal Caribbean or the accessible fun of Carnival, your perfect cruise awaits on the horizon, promising a treasure trove of memories and experiences.

Loyalty Programs

If you plan to take many cruises, the loyalty programs offered by Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line can add a significant layer of value to your experience. And sticking with one cruise line will have it’s perks.

Both programs are designed to reward returning guests, but they do so in ways that reflect their unique brand philosophies and guest experiences.

Carnival’s VIFP Club is all about enhancing the fun aspect of cruising. Starting as a Blue member and progressing up to Diamond status, the program injects each cruise with extra joy through perks that range from complimentary beverages to priority boarding.

The more you cruise with Carnival, the more points you gather, leading to richer rewards like onboard credits and exclusive VIFP parties. This program is tailored to recognize and reward the festive spirit of Carnival’s guests, making each cruise more enjoyable than the last.

Royal Caribbean’s Crown & Anchor Society , on the other hand, emphasizes exclusivity and premium experiences as you move from Gold to Pinnacle Club status.

The rewards system is structured to offer tangible benefits that enhance the convenience and luxury of your cruise experience.

Perks like priority check-in, balcony discounts, and access to exclusive lounges with complimentary refreshments are designed to make loyal cruisers feel special and valued.

For those who appreciate a sense of prestige and enjoy being recognized for their loyalty, Royal Caribbean’s program is incredibly appealing.

Both loyalty programs offer their own versions of special treatment:

• Carnival’s VIFP Club perks include welcome back parties, priority embarkation, and complimentary drinks, enhancing the social and fun aspects of your cruise.
• Royal Caribbean’s Crown & Anchor Society benefits focus on improving the cruising experience with practical amenities like priority check-in, onboard booking bonuses, and exclusive events, adding a touch of luxury to your journey.

Your preference might depend on what you value more: Carnival’s approach is perfect for those who love being part of a fun-loving community, with perks that celebrate the joy of cruising.

Royal Caribbean’s program, meanwhile, caters to those who prefer a more refined set of benefits that elevate the cruise experience itself.

Which One Is Right For You?

Choosing the best cruise line between Royal Caribbean and Carnival ultimately depends on what you value most in a vacation. Royal Caribbean leads with its innovative ships and adrenaline-pumping activities, making it ideal for those seeking a high-tech, adventure-filled journey.

Its offerings cater to both families and individuals who crave cutting-edge entertainment and a wide range of onboard experiences.

Carnival, however, shines with its budget-friendly options and a focus on fun, lively atmospheres that appeal to families, first-time cruisers, and those looking for a more relaxed, festive experience. With its diverse dining options and engaging entertainment, Carnival excels in providing a joyous and accessible cruise experience.

In general, if your dream cruise includes the latest and greatest in ship design and technology, along with a plethora of activities for all ages, Royal Caribbean is the way to go.

But if you’re after great value, a fun atmosphere, and a cruise experience that delights with its variety of dining and entertainment options, Carnival will likely be your ship of choice.

Similar Posts

Virtual Try-Ons? See How Carnival Firenze’s Innovative Tech is Revolutionizing Cruise Shopping!

What’s Included In Royal Caribbean Cruise Fare? (& What’s EXTRA)

Carnival Cruise Gratuity Policy Sparks Heated Passenger Reactions

Carnival Drinks Menu And Prices Revealed!

Carnival Cruise Line Revamps Dining and Encourages Tipping for Room Service

Are Carnival Cruises All Inclusive? (Know THIS Before Your Book…)

Leave a reply cancel reply.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Cruise line showdown: Comparing Carnival, Disney and Royal Caribbean for families

When I first started cruising more than 25 years ago, the typical ship was heavy with honeymooners and retirees — the "newlywed and nearly dead," as the old joke goes. The most exciting thing for families on the top deck of many vessels, other than a pool, was a shuffleboard court. The line perhaps most associated with family cruising, Disney Cruise Line , didn't even exist yet. Things sure have changed.

Among the lines that dominate the industry, the game increasingly is all about families. The world's two biggest cruise operators — Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean — now draw hundreds of thousands of families a year and, along with smaller players Norwegian Cruise Line and MSC Cruises, are increasingly packing their ships with every sort of family-friendly attraction imaginable, from massive waterslides and deck-top "sky rides" to go-kart tracks, bumper-car pavilions and laser-tag courses. Carnival is even planning a roller coaster for its next vessel .

In short, ships are becoming floating versions of the most over-the-top family resorts on land and there's never been a more exciting time to try family cruising. That is, if you can figure out the right ship and cruise line for you.

Related: Why now is the best time to save money on a cruise

For a first-timer , booking a family cruise can be more than a bit overwhelming. Each of the aforementioned lines has a different vibe, and no two ships — even vessels from the same series — are exactly alike.

What's more, pricing for family cruises is all over the map. A sailing with Disney can cost two or three times as much per day as a sailing with Carnival, Norwegian or MSC.

Below we offer considerations and pricing comparisons for three of the biggest players in the family cruise market: Disney, Royal Caribbean and Carnival.

Cruise lines overview

You might assume Disney is the Hercules of family cruising — the all-powerful competitor with no rival. But in the cruise world, Disney is still somewhat of a niche player. With just four ships compared to the 52 operated by family cruise giants Carnival and Royal Caribbean, Disney is like the cruising equivalent of Olaf from "Frozen" — a bit secondary to the plot, if still much beloved. In terms of passenger capacity, Disney is currently barely a tenth the size of Royal Caribbean alone, and it doesn't offer nearly as diverse an array of home ports and itineraries.

Note though that Disney Cruise Line plans to launch three new ships in its Triton class with the 4,000-passenger Disney Wish set to premier in January 2022.

What Disney does offer that no one else can is Disney. From Disney tunes piped into cabin hallways and Disney-shaped food items on menus to Disney-themed evening shows and the promise of meeting your favorite Disney princess, Disney ships are mouse bait for the diehard Mickey lover. If Disney is your thing, nothing in cruising quite compares. Just be prepared to pay up big time for the privilege of sailing with Captain Mickey or Minnie (more on that in a moment).

Related: Cruising with a family: Booking two staterooms for the price of one

Carnival long has claimed to be the biggest cruise line for families, with more than 800,000 children a year traveling on its 26 ships (out of 5.2 million total passengers). Known for its affordability as well as its lively, unpretentious, fun-focused vibe, this is the most budget option of the three lines we are comparing. You're likely to pay considerably less to sail with Carnival than Royal Caribbean or Disney.

For families craving the mega-resort experience, there's nothing quite like a Royal Caribbean vessel. The biggest of the line's 26 ships are more than 70% bigger than the biggest Disney and Carnival ships afloat and feature a lot more "stuff" that will get your kids' hearts racing — everything from rock-climbing walls and surfing pools to skydiving simulators and ice-skating rinks. Royal Caribbean also will offer you a lot more choices when it comes to itineraries. The line will have seven ships in Europe this summer, for instance, compared to one for Disney and three for Carnival. (Carnival, it should be noted, is a line that primarily focuses on cruises out of U.S. ports that are easy for its budget-conscious customers to reach by car or with a short, inexpensive flight.)

Related: How to book a cruise using miles and points

Comparing prices: A specific example

In general, on very similar itineraries, you'll a pay a premium — sometimes a huge premium — to take your teens and toddlers on a Disney ship instead of a Royal Caribbean ship, and both of those lines will cost you more than Carnival. Just how much more? We priced similar summer sailings to the Caribbean on the three lines and found a hypothetical family of four would pay about 2.6 times more to get aboard a Royal Caribbean ship than a Carnival ship and more than four times that to sail with Disney.

For the comparison, we looked at specific seven-night Eastern Caribbean sailings offered by each line out of Port Canaveral, Florida, at the beginning of August. We chose this routing because it allowed for one of the most apples-to-apples matchups you can make between the brands. All three of the companies have positioned one of their newest, snazziest vessels in Port Canaveral for seven-night Caribbean sailings.

In Carnival's case, it's Carnival Breeze, which debuted in 2012 and is one of the line's newer Vista-class vessels. For Royal Caribbean, it's Harmony of the Seas, which began sailing in 2016 and is part of the line's popular Oasis class. Disney's contender in the market is Disney Fantasy, the line's newest ship. It debuted in 2012, just two months before Carnival Breeze.

Related: Which Cruise Ship Cabin Category Should Your Family Book?

When pricing, we assumed we were booking a family with two adults and two children ages 8 and 12 who would share a single cabin. We found:

• The least expensive cabin available for Carnival Breeze at the time of our pricing would have set our family back $2,020.56 (an average fare of $562 per person, plus $139.64 per person in taxes and fees). For that, our family would have gotten an Interior cabin measuring 185 square feet. Such rooms have two twin beds that convert into a king bed, plus two beds that pull down from the wall.
• The least expensive cabin on Royal Caribbean's Harmony of the Seas costs $5,310.80 (an average fare of $1,213.75 per person, plus $113.95 each in taxes and fees). Notably, that higher price would have gotten our family a cabin measuring just 149 square feet — nearly 20% smaller than the cabin on Carnival Breeze. As with Carnival, it was an interior cabin — in this case with two twin beds that convert into a king bed and a double sofa bed.
• The least expensive cabin on Disney Fantasy costs a relatively sky-high $8,259.16 (an average fare of $1,959.44 per person, plus $105.35 each in taxes and fees). For that, our family would have gotten a Standard Inside Stateroom that measures 169 square feet — a bit bigger than the comparable cabin on Harmony of the Seas but smaller than the one on Carnival Breeze. Such rooms have a queen bed, a sofa that converts into a single bed and a pull-down bunk.

Trading up to a balcony cabin: The differential stays the same

Sometimes the cheapest cabin on a ship just won't do, so we also priced the cost of trading up to a balcony cabin on each of the vessels — an exercise that helps to illustrate two big things.

First: A "splurge" on a balcony cabin versus an inside cabin isn't nearly as costly as many people think. In our pricing test, passengers would only have to pony up 1% more for a balcony cabin on Royal Caribbean and just 4% on Disney Cruise Line. Carnival was the outlier with its balcony cabin pricing out 26% more expensive than an interior (which isn't always the case).

Second: The premium you'll pay for a Disney or Royal Caribbean ship versus a Carnival ship is roughly the same when booking a balcony as it is when booking an entry-level cabin. In this case, we found our family of four would pay double to get on Harmony of the Seas than Carnival Breeze and four times more to get on Disney Fantasy. Specifically:

• The least expensive balcony cabin on Carnival Breeze would have cost our family $2,554.56 (an average of $499 per person, plus $139.64 per person in taxes and fees). For that they would have gotten a Cove Balcony that has basically the same footprint as the previously priced interior cabin (its interior space is an identical 185 square feet) with the addition of a 45-square-foot balcony.
• The least expensive balcony cabin available on Harmony of the Seas costs $5,363.80 ($1,227 per person, plus $113.95 each in taxes and fees). For that, you get a cabin overlooking the ship's Boardwalk amusement area with 182 square feet of interior space and a 52-square-foot balcony.

• The least expensive balcony cabin on Disney Fantasy costs $8,609.16 ($2,046.94 per person, plus $105.35 per person in taxes and fees). This for what the line calls a Deluxe Oceanview Stateroom with Extended Veranda — Mickey sure has a fondness for long names. These cabins have 204 square feet of interior space, plus a 43-square-foot balcony. The room has a queen bed, single convertible sofa, upper bull-down bed (in some) and a split bath design with tub and shower (in most).

Related: The Best Credit Cards for Booking Cruises

Going big with suites and concierge-level service

For those willing to splurge on even bigger cabins and upgraded service, the comparisons between the ships get more complicated.

Carnival offers relatively few suites on most of its vessels. Fewer than 75 of the 1,845 cabins on Carnival Breeze are suites. The line also lacks a premium "concierge class" of cabins that come with dedicated concierge service and other extras.

Royal Caribbean's recent vessels, by contrast, are awash with suites in a wide range of sizes, including enormous (and super-pricy), two-deck-high complexes that are among the most luxurious accommodations at sea. Royal Caribbean, in recent years, also has added a concierge-class-like program for suite passengers on some of its vessels (Harmony of the Seas among them). Called Royal Suite Class, it offers more polished service and exclusive access to shipboard restaurants, lounges and attractions.

Like Carnival, Disney offers relatively few suites on its ships. Just 21 of the 1,250 cabins on Disney Fantasy are suites. But the line does offer exclusive Concierge cabins that come with access to a concierge team that can help arrange onboard activities and services. On Disney Fantasy, the Concierge service is available with all 21 suites, plus 20 nonsuite Concierge Family Oceanview Stateroom with Verandah cabins. In addition to concierge service, all 41 rooms come with access to a private concierge lounge and sun deck. Other perks include priority boarding.

For our hypothetical family:

• The least expensive suite on Carnival Breeze — a 340-square-foot Ocean Suite — priced at $3,934.56 (an average of $844 per person, plus $139.64 in taxes and fees). This is, notably, still half as expensive than even the least expensive cabin available on Disney Fantasy.
• For the suite life on Royal Caribbean, our family would pay at least $7,538 ($1,884.50 per person, plus $113.95 in taxes and fees). That's for a Junior Suite, which measures 287 square feet plus an 80-square-foot balcony.
• The least expensive suite on Disney Fantasy priced at a stratospheric $23,546.60 ($5,781.30 per person, plus $105.28 per person in taxes and fees). That's for a 622-square-foot Concierge 1-Bedroom Suite with Verandah. That said, you can get into one of the nonsuite Concierge cabins for about half that cost. Disney doesn't call those cabins suites, but they measure a respectable 306 square feet. That's not much smaller than the smallest suites on the other ships.

Related: Alaska cruise tips: best itineraries, ports and ships

What's included and what's not

As regular cruisers know, the fares that lines quote for sailings include more than just your lodging. For all the ships in our comparison, the price also includes breakfast, lunch and dinner (at main restaurants and buffets); nightly entertainment in showrooms; and a significant swath of onboard activities. What's not included are alcoholic and, in some cases, nonalcoholic drinks (Disney offers free sodas on its ships; the others don't); meals at "specialty" restaurants; spa and salon services; shore tours and some onboard activities.

We won't run through every extra charge here. But consider that you'll pay around $6 to $7 for a beer on all three ships, and a cocktail can run anywhere from $7 to $14 (in general, Harmony of the Seas has the highest drink prices). Among extra-charge restaurants, you'll find a flat fee of $38 per person at the signature steakhouse on Carnival Breeze, a tad less than the $43-per-person charge for the Chops Grille steakhouse on Harmony of the Seas. Disney Fantasy doesn't have a steakhouse, but its signature, adults-only Palo eatery is in the ballpark at an additional $40 per person.

You'll also pay extra for the service charges that have become commonplace on ships. For most cabins on Carnival, Royal Caribbean and Disney vessels, a family of four would pay $391.72, $406 and $378 per week, respectively, in such fees. Passengers in suites pay more.

The bottom line: It's frustratingly easy for a family of four on any of these ships to run up $1,000 or more in extra charges.

Family attractions

Each of the ships in our comparison is among the most alluring in their respective fleets for families. You'll find watery play zones, family pools and other kiddie lures on the top decks of all three vessels, and plenty of supervised kid zones in their interiors.

Specifically, Carnival has loaded the top of Carnival Breeze with one of its signature, family-focused WaterWorks waterpark areas that has two giant waterslides, a soaking "dump bucket" and other get-you-wet features; a suspended-in-the-sky ropes course; a miniature golf course; and a basketball court. Family attractions on the inside of the vessel include a 3D theater with moving seats and special effects (a cruise ship rarity).

Not to be outdone, Disney has given Disney Fantasy one of the most innovative deck-top attractions at sea, the 765-foot-long AquaDuck "water coaster." Disney Fantasy's top deck also is home to a family pool, kiddie waterslide, kiddie play area, miniature golf course and basketball court. Its insides are loaded with some of the most elaborate children's play areas at sea — all Disney themed, of course.

Still, when it comes to family-friendly attractions, neither Carnival Breeze nor Disney Fantasy comes close to offering the array of options available on Harmony of the Seas.

At 226,963 gross register tons, the ship is about 75% bigger than its two competitors, and all that extra space allows for a crazy array of amusements. You'll find a waterpark area with three large slides; a separate dry slide that plunges nine decks (Royal Caribbean says it's 10, but don't be fooled; it counts a Deck 13 that doesn't exist); three main pools and separate surfing pools; a watery kiddie play zone; two rock-climbing walls; a miniature golf course; a basketball court; and a zip line. There's also an outdoor Boardwalk area that mimics the Jersey Shore with a carousel and arcade. Teens have their own onboard disco, part of interior kid zones spread over parts of two interior decks.

Crowds and service

On all three of the ships in our comparison, you're going to feel the crowds at times (just ask TPG Family founder Summer Hull, aka Mommy Points, who recently wrote about the pool area pileup she saw during a Disney sailing). This is just par for the course on big, mass-market vessels that sail with thousands of people.

Still, when it comes to feeling the jam, there are some significant differences between the three ships in our comparison.

For starters, you'll often find more people packed onto Carnival Breeze than Disney Fantasy, even though the two ships are roughly the same size (about 130,000 gross register tons). Carnival Breeze can hold up to 4,891 passengers if every berth is filled, about 22% more than Disney Fantasy. The differential is even more notable if you look at the "double occupancy" numbers for the two ships — the number of people they would carry if two people occupied every cabin. Carnival Breeze's capacity based on double occupancy is 3,690 — nearly 48% higher than the comparable number for Disney Fantasy. Packing in more people on a similarly sized ship is one of the key ways Carnival keeps it price point low. Another way is by keeping tight controls on staffing. Carnival Breeze sails with a staff of 1,386 — 72 fewer than Disney Fantasy. The result: A crew-to-passenger ratio, based on total occupancy, of about 1 to 3.5 for Carnival Breeze versus 1 to 3.2 for Disney Fantasy.

Comparing crew-to-passenger ratios on ships can offer a rough guide to their service levels, though there are caveats to this approach. A significant chunk of the extra staff on Disney Fantasy are involved in the ship's entertainment program, which is far more elaborate. It doesn't necessarily mean Disney is devoting more staff to service positions in restaurants, bars and other areas. Meanwhile, of the three vessels in the comparison, it is Harmony of the Seas — the ship with, by far, the highest passenger capacity — which boasts the best crew-to-passenger ratio. While the ship can sail with up to 6,687 people, it operates with 2,200 crew. That gives it a crew-to-passenger ratio, based on total occupancy, of around 1 to 3.

Related: Which cruise brand is best for you?

Destinations and private islands

As noted above, our pricing comparison for the ships assumes an Eastern Caribbean itinerary out of Port Canaveral, Florida. While roughly similar, the routings that each of the vessels take are not identical:

• Carnival Breeze stops at Amber Cove, Dominican Republic; St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands; San Juan, Puerto Rico; and Grand Turk in the Turks & Caicos.
• Harmony of the Seas also visits San Juan, but substitutes St. Kitts and Royal Caribbean's private island in the Bahamas, Perfect Day at CocoCay , for the other ports.
• Like Carnival Breeze, Disney Fantasy heads to St. Thomas, but combines it with visits to Tortola in the British Virgin Islands and Disney's private island in the Bahamas, Castaway Cay.

When it comes to private islands, Royal Caribbean's Perfect Day is the most elaborate by far. The line is just finishing a $200 million overhaul of the getaway that has brought a major waterpark with 13 waterslides, including the tallest one in North America; the Caribbean's largest freshwater pool; the Caribbean's largest wave pool and a balloon ride that takes you up 450 feet above the island. There's also an exclusive — and expensive — private beach club coming in December.

Related: Best Cruise Line Private Islands for Families

Disney's Castaway Cay is more of a traditional cruise line private island with beach areas (snorkels, tubes and floats are available for rent), a small floating waterslide complex and games such as volleyball. You also can rent bikes for a bit of exploring around the island. Paddleboards, kayaks and aquabikes are also available.

While Carnival doesn't have a private island of its own, two of the stops on Carnival Breeze's itinerary are private port developments built by its parent company that come with their own pool areas and more. The 25-acre Amber Cove development has a sprawling pool with a swim-up bar, waterslides, zip lines and private cabanas as well as bars, restaurants and shops. The 18-acre Grand Turk Cruise Center complex has its own pool area, beach areas and cabanas as well as bars, restaurants and shops.

Bottom line

I've sailed on all these lines many times over the years, and they all offer a lot for families. Which one is right for you? The answer depends on a number of factors specific to you and your family: your budget, the ages of your kids, their personalities and interests in specific activities and the destinations that you hope to see.

For those on a tight budget, Carnival is hard to beat — as the pricing comparison above makes clear. But if you have a little more wiggle room with your pocketbook, there are good arguments for paying up for a week with Royal Caribbean or Disney. When it comes to the quality of service, entertainment and dining, it's a little bit of "you get what you pay for" with the lines.

As noted above, you'll find a higher ratio of crew-to-passengers on Royal Caribbean and Disney ships, and all those extra crew members do make a difference in the experience. The difference is particularly notable when it comes to entertainment offerings, with both Royal Caribbean and Disney fielding much more elaborate shows with bigger casts and name-brand stories. Royal Caribbean's Harmony of the Seas, for instance, features a 90-minute adaptation of one of Broadway's biggest crowd-pleasers, "Grease," in a soaring theater that puts many on Broadway to shame, plus an outdoor "aquatheater" that's home to dazzling aerial performances. Disney's ships are chock full of Disney-themed entertainment that wins kudos for its high production values.

With its greater number of "older kid" amusements, such as surfing pools and rock-climbing walls, Harmony of the Seas is a particularly good choice for families with teens. Disney ships, like many of the Disney parks, aim younger with their attractions and are probably best when your kids are in the 6- to 12-year-old range. Just remember that you're paying a hefty "Disney premium" to get on board. If you're a big Disney fan, it makes sense. If you're not, it probably doesn't.

Is your family thinking about a cruise vacation? Here are some more insights:

• These Are the Best Cruise Lines for 2019
• Interesting Way to Save Money on a Disney Cruise
• Are River Cruises Right for Kids?
• An Overview of Cruise Line Loyalty Programs

Gene Sloan has written about cruising for more than 25 years and for many years oversaw USA TODAY's award-winning cruise site, USA TODAY Cruises. He's sailed on nearly 150 ships.

Featured graphic by Abbie Winters